Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Has this been mentioned before? I put it as a spoiler to be on the safe side. I can see everyone in the Enchanted Forest debating who should find Emma and Henry. Maybe Charming decides that Hook should go because Hook saved Charming’s life in Neverland. Basically, Charming owes his mate a favor. I like it! I think a duel between Neal and Hook to decide who goes after Emma would be fun to watch. I don’t condone violence but this is a fairytale/fantasy show afterall.
[adrotate group="5"]hookian wrote: I’m also very upset with the way we’re treated on this forum. I mean I get that Captain Swan is the most popular couple on Once going from media websites and social media but that doesn’t give them the right to censor us here. Unfortunately this place is a safe haven because everywhere else on the forum we get chastised gained up on, and sometimes can’t even share our opinions or facts. It’s ridiculous. No wonder I rarely go on this forum. It certainly isn’t a very welcomed place for CS fans.
Yeah it’s sad. I think everyone is just resentful of all the time CS is getting – even though Emma is the main protagonist of this show and it CERTAINLY makes sense that her love story would get the lions share of the time. *sigh* At least A&E and the media know that CS is VERY popular with us fans (ps I got a coworkers wife to start watching ONCE – she ships CS now! And i’ve never even met her or talked to her lol. RESISTANCE IS FUTILE)
I agree with you both!
I don’t understand the petitions and tweeting the writers because Hook/CS get so much screen time. Also, the profanity some people use on their rants (NOT ON THIS FORUM!) is truly astounding! So much negativity for a show about fairytales, princes and princesses? Really? The most ridiculous thing I’ve read on another website is that Emma is with Hook because he is hot. PLEASE!!! Umm, that is just an added bonus and besides, Emma is pretty stunning herself. As a matter of fact, the whole cast is filled with attractive people. Heaven forbid, Emma actually likes talking to Hook.
Rainbow kisses and unicorn stickers to everyone!
Amazing – 500 pages! Congrats!
I am still relatively new here and was wondering if my shipmates could help me. I searched the forum about Emma’s new apartment. I read that Emma may be in NYC because Neal used to live there. As you know there are thousands of posts. So where is it theorized that Emma is in NYC because the tall buildings remind her of the beanstalk she climbed with Hook? Or because of her adventure with Hook Emma is drawn to tall buildings?
Eala, thanks for all the gifsets you have been posting. They are fantastic! It does feel awkward when I am out using my smartphone reading this thread and all these images of Emma and Hook kissing start popping up.
It would be fun to see all the characters dressed up for a wedding, especially Emma and Hook. I would love a scene where Hook sees Emma all dressed up in a ball gown or any type of dress. It would have been funny if Emma was wearing that red dress or something similar when she opened the door in New York. I think he would have fainted!
Ok, for some reason, I never thought about relating the Emma running into Hook & Tink to the goodbye…but what you said finally makes it work for me! I admit, when I first saw the Hook/Emma goodbye, I was NOT impressed. The rewatch(es) and gifs and thoughts about it have helped, but I still was not 100% thrilled with the “good”. But, when you put the entire day together, really, the last real interaction Emma had with Hook was when she saw him with Tink. I think Emma saw right through the “perhaps” but she definitely had a reaction that she didn’t have time to process. Hook made Emma feel many things before she ran into him with Tink, but jealousy was not one of them. If I’m maybe kind of thinking I have feelings for someone and those feelings confuse me, shock me, terrify me and then I find out I can’t even do anything about it because my entire life as I know it is getting taken away from me, NOW the walking away from Neal and letting Hook approach her, and the “good” make sense. Oh, now I’m happy.
Oh wow, I’m glad my rambling made sense to you. It’s been a while since I wrote anything remotely analytical. It is so fun reading other people’s thoughts about Hook and Emma, especially here. It really helps to fill in the gaps. I read the other threads also but I haven’t come across anything to change my mind about Captain Swan
So glad they aren’t doing a baby switch story line! That’s why I quit watching daytime tv. Perhaps the babies will be kidnapped because they are products of true love and are magical. Maybe the Wicked Witch or whatever villain wants to raise the kids to be evil or use their magic for evil. Think of Star Wars and the Emperor turning Anakin evil. Maybe Regina will be more of mentor to Emma – kind of like Obi-wan to Luke Skywalker. Lol! Sorry about the Star Wars stuff!
Didn’t Ariel and Eric get married on a ship? Although very unlikely, a Hook and Emma would be fun. They could get married on a pirate ship.
OMG! captaineala thanks for posting that lovely essay by sincerelygsh. By far, one of the best posts comparing the difference between the Captain Swan and Swan Fire goodbye.
After watching 3×11, I was convinced that Emma’s love for Neal was not romantic in nature – not true love – because of the goodbyes. And yes, the expressions that Jennifer and Colin display in that scene are amazing to watch! Remember in Season 1 when Kathryn tells Regina that she is letting David go? Kathryn shows Regina the pictures of David and Mary Margaret and says something like “Do you see the way they look at each other? They are in love.” This so applies to Hook and Emma and of course Snow and Charming.
I just want to add, I think Emma didn’t approach Hook first because she was still hurt from seeing Tinkerbell and Hook together. That incident hurt her deeply and the jealousy completely took her by surprise. Remember Rumple telling Emma in 3×01 that she was just a bails bond person – still looking for evidence? The Tink/Hook incident made her doubt Hook’s feelings for her. On the other hand, Hook approached Emma after she spoke to Neal. He was doing exactly what he said – backing off. He obviously witnessed the platonic goodbye between Emma and Neal and felt free to tell her – well, we all know what he said!
Hi CS shippers! I have been lurking here since the Winter Finale. Add me to the list of moms shipping Captain Swan. Seems like there is a pattern here…must be a reason moms love Hook and Emma. Hmmm?
I was in the gym (trying to get back into Good Form!) this morning walking on the treadmill and reading this thread/forum. I was surprised at all the Smoochies!! Loved it all! Emma and Hook’s first kiss was awesome. Not a surprise since I saw the promo but I was caught off guard by how hot it was.
