Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
@The Fairest wrote:
@MagicKingdomღ wrote:
Judging by what I saw, it really did seem as if Hook was going to kill Belle because he thought she was useless. When she refused to give him the information he wanted, he slapped her and said “so pretty and yet so useless.” And then preceded to raise his hook as if to kill her. The only reason why Belle survived is because of Regina…oddly enough. 😆
But like others have said, he’s a villain, so he’ll behave as one. Trying to justify his actions isn’t going to make them any less terrible. I had to learn that with Rumpel. I love him, but I’m not going to excuse his behavior. Sometimes our love for a character gets in the way of our judgement.
If he thought she were protecting Rumpel, then in his mind, would she be any better than him? That’s the reasoning I put into that. I’m still confused by why he would just randomly want to kill her for being of no use to him. Hook puts calculation into everything he does. He’s not the type to lash out with his emotions like that.
I disagree. We don’t know enough about Hook’s character to know if he’s that calculated. Rumpel is calculating. Cora is calculating. All we’ve seen from Hook is that he’s a vengeful pirate with a strange sense of “honor.” Which apparently includes taking an innocent girl’s heart and almost killing another innocent girl just because she wouldn’t do what he asked.
Yeah, I’ve never viewed Hook as calculating either. His move with Aurora’s heart might have been calculated, but his actions with Belle probably weren’t.
And I agree. Trying to justify someone’s actions is just unnecessary. There are people who make excuses for Rumpel killing Milha or Regina killing her father all the time. I’m not going to do that with Hook. The scene in the jail cell was very straightforward.
Are we talking about the jail cell with Belle or with the Princess Squad?
About him being calculating.. I think that comes and goes, sometimes he is very calculating while other times he isn’t so…this is a pirate that has survived 300+ years he had to learn to be calculating in order to truly survive
The heart thing with Aurora was him being calculating (he didn’t truly want to kill or well he didn’t really care) he knew her heart would get him in Cora’s good books again so he took it…and then he gave it back (which i’m not condoning in any way I was like seriously Killian? Seriously)
Ugh i hate it when people try to justify a character’s actions it’s like they are villains of course they are going to do evil things..that just makes redeeming them a lot more interesting (because if Regina and Rumple can be redeemed so can Hook)
[adrotate group="5"]I know!!
Captain Swanners/Knightly Hookers are the best… we were loosing yesterday (last place) and now we’re in 1st place
I find it funny that’s it’s basically the extended charming family (aka dwarves/granny/red) + Hook…maybe this is the righteous crowd he falls in with? I’m thinking they are either pulling Emma out of the whole or it’s the Giant
@An Empty Heart wrote:
@TheBee wrote:
Yeah, Cora is pretty evil. I think she scares the crap out of Hook, too. That’s why I think he was so willing to work with Emma in the very beginning, and why Cora accused Hook of choosing “her”. He wants revenge on Rumpel yeah, but he also wants to get away from her!
Hmm, we’ll see. He took Aurora’s heart and was more than willing to kill Belle. His actions confuse me sometimes.
I can’t shake the feeling that Barrett with have some sort of connection to Neal’s life.
That’s my thinking as well. 😉
but he gave back her heart…yeah he was willing to kill Belle he’s a pirate he is looking out for himself and his revenge… He knows Belle is important because Regina wouldn’t really put that much emphasis in locking her up if she wasn’t
(and honestly the whole back and forth just gives more ammo to my Peter Pan theory hehehe) btw Hook doesn’t have magical abilities Regina enchanted his hook to be able to take out 1 heart (which he used for Aurora)
Same!
