Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
They might have messed up there I guess. But where Again are we told that Blue is not able to tell lies? and by whom? I dont remember that.
[adrotate group="5"]Neal was the one who decided to take the action which ultimately led to his death.
As I mentioned in a post above, had Neal and Belle not discovered Zelena’s plot then, and only then, would the blame lie in Zelena’s hands. ….
He was an adult who made a choice, despite Belle’s warnings and concerns, therefore he must bare the blame. Adults don’t get to make informed decisions and cast blame on someone else when it doesn’t work out. And by informed I mean he was informed by Lumiere that the whole thing was a set-up by the Wicked Witch, which should have been the only information he needed to make the right decision.Can I chime in a bit here 🙂 interesting topic.
Yes it was Neals own choice when he discovered the truth. But Z will still bare the blame partly since it was her choice to manipulate Neal knowing what would happen to him.
Same as if someone puts a loaded gun in a suicidal persons hand and wait for the person to pull the trigger. Thats the persons own choice, but the gun wouldnt be there if it wasnt for the other guy.
lol… never mind then. This was a scary thread to post on. Funny with that strange red stripes and triangles that came on my screen before when I posted the first time.. perhaps it was trying to warn me.
I wont disturb you no more here then.
Jaxer@
“share similar thoughts without having to invest energy into explaining to those who don’t understand or are taken aback about why they feel what they do. Different strokes for different folks and all that.”
yeah sure I understand that. Its just me that likes disgussing Things with people when they feel different then me. But if you all dont want that on this thread I wont post those thoughts here then.
Again just because I asked why you feel that way. Dont mean I think you are wrong.
RG@
“Being shocked that we’re sad or angry or upset is just another way of saying, “man. You guys don’t GET how much sense this makes!!””
No that it is not. For me its just a couriosity as to how and why people can feel so different about it. And it is not that it is Neal that you are sad about that surprised me. Because as I wrote I dont imagine myself being sad to that extent about Regina (My fave character) should her character die. I even wrote a fanfic in which she sort of died- that actually did make me very sad.. lol.
I think it is that…. and I am afraid to write this 🙂 …but that people can feel like this about a character on a tv show. Yes you loved that character and the show strikes a Deep cord in you somehow… but that just surprises me… since I dont feel the same… that is still not me saying you are wrong and I am right- Its just me saying we are different.
“I have no idea who has said it. But it has been said generally. By many. I do not single out people. And I am not so unbelievably passive aggressive that I would come here and talk about a member of this forum behind their back.”
Okay Im glad. But I did say it. And would never mind discussing it with someone who disagree.
RumplesGirl this is what I tried to post as a reply to one of your post on page 998. But without the quote because it didnt Work. You wrote that you hated and was tired of people bringing up “the real World argument” refering to Neals death. (In the real World good people also die and dont get happy endings sometimes.. etc)
I feel like this comment includes me in a round-about-way since I used those “real World arguments” when I started this thread – https://oncepodcast.com/forums/topic/is-this-show-still-about-hope-post-neals-death/But are stories not always grounded in some reality though? fairytales included, otherwise the stories would mean nothing to us.
Ive have no problem with you disagreeing with me on that RG and other SF’ers. I wouldnt have had a problem if you had posted this view in that thread I mentioned. Ofcourse that is intirely your choice. I could be wrong and your comment was not with my thread in mind- then I apologize. I just find it sad if we can not discuss Things at all on these threads when we disagree about stuff. It is in the disagreements that the most fun and learning is found IMO.
I must admit I am surprised at how this story of Neals death is affecting people on here. It sure Means alot to you Guys. Im not saying that because I think you are wrong to feel that way. It just surprises me that is all. I love OUAT and my fave character is Regina, if her character died on the show and I felt like it was badly written I think I would be very sad and angry to. Only I can’t imagine it would be to as great an extent that it has for some of you Guys, the way you Express it anyway. Again, Im not saying that because I think it is wrong of you. people feel what they feel and feelings are a good thing.So I don’t see this one anywhere else in the thread and I just found it and um…
I don’t always check out the promo stills, but have they ever released something like that that so clearly centered on extras? Seems kind of odd to me that the only character in the shot is Blue and she’s off to the side. Hmm very suspecious. Lots of crack theories forming.. could they be shady fairies? 🙂 you never know.
Hello everyone. I’ve never posted to these forums before…………. Life can be harsh and unfair, but hope and love shine through in even the most unlikely of places. And it’s these moments that make everything worthwhile, worth fighting for. That’s what this show is about for me and I can’t wait to see where it will take us next.
Hear Hear!! and Agree Agree!! with all that 🙂 If this was your first post Sheharazade, you need to get out of hiding and into the habit of writing more posts please. Loved reading your view, it was very well put.
