Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
@EnchantedOne wrote:
What an Awesome idea…
I want to be the keeper of Rumples cane and the look in his eye when he is gazing at Belle…
Aww! Too sweet! Dang it! I wish I thought of that. 😆
[adrotate group="5"]Welcome to the forum Karen! Love the username by the way! 😀
And I see you’re a fellow Rumpel lover as well. ALWAYS. A .GOOD. CHOICE!!!!!
@Beauty & the Beast wrote:
Bring the convo from the Belle thread to this thread. 😀
Midnight Dreary suggested that Rumpelstiltskin gave the Evil Queen the wrong ingredients for the curse. I think she may actually be right. Rumpel said that in order to enact the curse, you must sacrifice the heart of the person you love most. Well, if that’s the case, how Rumpel even know that? Everyone Rumpel ever loved was either dead or missing by the time he began working on the curse. His son was gone, his first wife was gone, Belle was gone. How would he know that the curse required the heart of the person you love most when he himself didn’t have the key ingredient? I think Rumpel gave the Evil Queen the wrong ingredients to accomplish two things:
1. He honestly didn’t want to give Regina the real curse and the only way to both satisfy her demands and save himself at the same time was to give her the wrong ingredients. So, Regina did in fact cast a curse, however, I believe it was a different curse or the “wrong” curse. If this is true, then no mater what Regina does in Storybrooke, Mr. Gold will always have the upper hand because he’s the only one knows that Regina cast the wrong curse.
2. I also believe that Rumpel gave the Evil Queen the wrong ingredients out of petty revenge. Even though Rumpel believed that it was Belle’s father that caused her eventaul suicide, I could easily see Rumpel placing blame on the Evil Queen as well. In his eyes, if it wasn’t for the Evil Queen’s intervention and manipulation of Belle, then the tragedy would have never happened. Belle would have returned home, she would have never kissed him, and Rumpel would have never accused her of working with the Evil Queen. I know, it sounds loaded and petty, but the death of a loved causes a person to blame everyone who was involved. And unfortunately for Regina, that includes her.
So, as punishment, Rumpel lies and tells the Evil Queen that the heart of the person you love most is needed for the curse, when in fact, the main ingredient was probably true love. So, Rumpel gets to keep his curse, defeat Regina and ruthlessly punish her by forcing her to sacrifice her own father all at the same time.
Man this guy is scary. 😯
Wow! Great points, Beauty and the Beast.
That’s why I tend to place all my bets on Mr. Gold. Even though, the introduction of Belle could possibly make Mr. Gold’s position more unstable.
It’s ok, hjbau. I completely understand. I hope you continue to chat with us. 😀
I also understand the human vs. character conflict. As viewers, we tend to throw out human values and standards and immerse ourselves into the world of make-believe. It becomes more and more difficult to tell right from wrong.
Ok, I’m calling that after Rumpel became the Dark One, Bae ran away to Neverland and became either Peter Pan or a Lost Boy. I also think this is why Rumpel hates fairies so much. The fairies kept him away from his son. Mabe that’s why Rumpel was so desperate to get the fairy-god mother’s wand. Maybe he needs the wand of a fairy to gain access to Neverland.
@weedith wrote:
Give them a few sessions of couples counseling with Archie and they will be shopping for china patterns! 😀
weedith, I think I love you. 😆
If I'm not mistaken, Rumpel will be attending therapy sessions with Archie in episode 1×19, the same episode where we learn more about Bae.
@hjbau wrote:
I agree that Belle seemed conflicted in the bar with Grumpy, but even if that is so i still don’t think she should go back to him. He is just too dangerous. We do need more information though. I am sorry i will try and stay out of this thread.
Aww, why? I love your opinions. I love discussing different points of view with my fellow Once lovers. PLEASE COME BACK!!! 😥
@hjbau wrote:
Really? I felt like Belle’s final words to Rumpel were disgust and she tried to hurt him. She called him a coward. Something like being left with a chipped cup and an empty heart or something. I don’t remember. I thought Belle was angry when she left the dungeon.
It felt like a mixture of anger, regret and desperation. When Rumpel entered the dungeon, he commanded her to leave. As Belle was leaving the dungeon, she turned around and gave him a piece of he rmind. But the way she said it seemed like she was trying to convince him to open his eyes and shake him up a little bit. And then there’s that scene in the bar where Belle was talking about lost love and how hearbroken she still was. She seemed to be full of conflicting emotions. I guess we’ll have to see.
