Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Snow and Regina are NOT Rumple and Belle. There was never a feud between them. Rumple made promises and grand speeches and loving declarations. He never tried to kill Belle, he never poisoned her, he never tried to kill her daughter. And Belle didn’t play a part in making Rumple loose what he loved most. The situations are vastly different.
I agree.
[adrotate group="5"]@RumplesGirl, I just want to say, I love you sweetie and you’ve been a great trooper through this whole discussion. I just wanted to applaud you for all the posts you’ve contributed to this discussion and I am behind you 100% all the way.
I can’t believe the interviewer didn’t at least make the correction in the write up that it’s Lana and not Lara.
1) When did you start shipping CS-
2) When did you start believing that Emma loves Hook/Killian?
3) When did you just know they were endgame?
This is good because I never really got a chance to talk about this.
1) After watching Tallahassee I knew I didn’t like Neal. I just couldn’t get behind the Emma going to jail helping her achieve her destiny thing. What also funny is that my girlfriend, she had a crush on Hook long before I did and a I have a weakness for accents. Anyway, I liked Hook and Emma’s dynamic in Tallahassee a lot better than SwanFire and it took me writing my first CS fanfic to really see the potential and fall in love with the ‘ship.
2) I think Emma started to fall in love with him in Neverland and when they came to back Storybrooke and we saw Emma uneasy without Hook beside her (The New Neverland) that’s when she started to really fall for him. Because again, like in the finale, she missed his presence and was confused about why he was keeping his distance. But their scene at the town line in Going Home is when she accepted her feelings for him and vice versa.
3) I believe Captain Swan is endgame because Killian puts Emma first in a way Neal never did. He has this amazing devotion to her and we’ve seen that no matter the circumstances, he isn’t swayed to run away from her. And it might sound crass, but if Neal and Emma were meant to be endgame, their scenes wouldn’t be overshadowed by Hook’s presence or reaction (especially in Neverland). Like the ‘I’m not going to stop fighting you line’ if it was meant yo be SwanFire, the camera wouldn’t need to cut to Hook watching and paying attention to his reaction. And Neal wouldn’t have died either. Or Emma wouldn’t have said that she wished he had stayed dead in Neverland because that’s not how true loved behave on this show.
I hope that makes sense.
A few night on the couch doesn’t fit the crime, nor one yelling match with Belle. You know what you spend a few nights on the couch for? When you miss your anniversary. Not for murdering someone in hopes of no one finding out.
Yes. I completely agree. Bless you @RumplesGirl for saying that. The punishment for Rumple should be proportionate to the crime and sleeping on the couch doesn’t fit it.
UGH! Stupid forums wont let me quote again >:(
This probably won’t make any sense to anyone here but I hope they’re like John and Aeryn from Farscape.
I LOVE Farscape! It’s on my rewatch list for this winter lol
The trick is to switch to text mode before hitting the quote link and then switch back to visual to edit.
Can I just say I love the idea of Outlaw Queen but some of you wanting Marian to die makes me really uneasy.
Think about: poor little hobbit Roland will have lost his mother twice!
Ideally, what I would want to happen is that Robin and Marian come to an understanding that he doesn’t love her the way he used to but they can still be parents to Roland and Marian will get to know the kinder Regina and no one dies.
I hope you’re wrong RG.
I know what you’re saying about off screen conversations. Like how Belle mentioned that she and her father are talking again.
We never saw them reconcile and I highly suspect that Moe wasn’t too happy to start that his daughter was going to marry the Dark One.
My head canon is that Belle fought Moe and for Moe, it came down to what makes Belle happy vs. does he really want to be estranged from his daughter? Probably no. So he gave Belle his blessing.
We’ve already seen Emma and Killian as a team and they work well together. But working together as allies vs. boyfriend/girlfriend will be different.
But Killian’s had a much longer track record in that he hasn’t been in a relationship for almost 300 years which trumps Emma’s ten years without love.
I look forward to seeing how they are as a couple.
This probably won’t make any sense to anyone here but I hope they’re like John and Aeryn from Farscape.
I would love it Belle and Rumple work things out together. I do hope however this is handled next season, everything isn’t wrapped up in a “talk” in one scene and its never dealt with again. I mean, look at us even — how many pages we’ve had dedicated to this topic? It’s probably close to 5-10 pages now.
