Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
[adrotate group="5"]
I don’t even view Killian as the villain in The Crocodile, in the flashbacks. Rumple was the villain. I’m a Rumple fan, so of course I was never happy with what Milah did either, but Rumple overreacted in a very bad way too.
I agree @ellemo78 Everything Hook did in season two, doesn’t even come nearly as close to Regina and Rumple’s crimes on the villainy scale. How many times did Hook fail in season two trying to enact his revenge? Even him constantly falling on the floor became a running joke and there’s a ‘ship crack name for that, Flook (which I think I even came up with).
That’s not Belle. That would be incredibly OOC for her. But for characters like Rumple and Regina, not so much. I think if Belle killed someone, she would have a huge meltdown about it. Bigger than Snow’s reaction after she killed Cora.
Define evil? The only time Belle acted out of character is when she was Lacey, she behaved the opposite of Belle. But Rumple still loved her.
Actually, he’s a lot closer to Byronic hero than a villain. there’s a great meta essay explaining why he is one here.
It just makes me so mad to continually read this stuff when Adam and Eddie have even come out and say that he was NEVER meant to be written as a villain. He was meant to fall in love with Emma and he’s not a lovesick puppy either. But you know, no one calls Rumple or Regina lovesick puppies either or undeserving of love and they were villains in season one!
Anyway, happy vibes, happy feels, tonight is OUR night guys. I can’t watch tonight but my cs feels and love goes out to all of you. But I’m 100% certain we will finally see Emma declare her true love for Killian and the haters will be silenced into oblivion and I can finally, properly write that section in my true love meta.
A word of advice guys, the new Captain Hook thread, don’t go in there. I was hoping it would be reasonable, sensible character development talk but it’s basically, Hook’s character is ruined since he fell in love with Emma. I made a response and you all are welcome to as well, but I am seriously, done with this crap. Especially after it was confirmed that Hook was always meant to fall in love with Emma.
The double-standards that exist in this fandom are disgusting. Truly.
Eta: @RumplesGirl closed the thread.
