Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
I haven’t been on this forum in months! New baby, big move, yada yada yada. 😉 Was really looking forward to the episode and I’m just so frustrated with the writers! There was SO MUCH stink’n potential, not only with FishHook, but with Ariel as a character on Once and they just threw it away!
[adrotate group="5"]So excited we got more info on the mermaids in the finale! And it looks like they’re evil too. I might like that twist, what do ya’ll think?
Yes! Honestly, Hook and (blank slate)Ariel don’t have anyone else they’d fit better with (IMO). Plus this would allow a more headstrong, not so innocent and “nice” Ariel that was only barely hinted at in the Disney movie, that could be a really fun character to watch.
Maybe we’ll learn about the mermaids that live there, but won’t see them until season 3?! I’d be ok with that. 😀
So I guess we know for sure that “Tamara” is not a mermaid. Definitely looks like they’ve pushed a/the mermaid story until next season. Bummer.
He’s a fine character, but there are too many more important characters that are getting lost or overlooked, adding him as a regular would make that problem even worse.
I agree with Sarah_TN. This show has the possibility of going completely overboard with characters. I liked episodes of season one, where they introduced a new character, but it was only for one or two episodes and it focused on this character’s relationship with the regulars. If the show stays on for many more seasons (which I hope!), then they can do the 1-2 episode thing per “new character” without them taking quite so much time away from the regulars.
Hahaha, so after watching the new episode last night I dreamt about Ariel in Storybrooke. She had legs, stuck on land, and emphasized her “out of place-ness” with her crazy bright dyed red hair, nose piercing, and tattoos (including a mermaid that took up most of her back). Her and Hook ended up together. 😆
@slurpeez108 wrote:
@Phee wrote:
Isn’t it fun when they throw a bunch of random numbers and whatnot at us and leave us to figure it out? Love seeing all the different ideas and interpretations. 🙂
Yeah, it’s a real doozy. *Head-hits-desk.* 😉
Phee wrote: @EvilQueen wrote:
Oh, and is it just me, or does Greg know a bit too much? As in, he didn’t tell Emma that he saw anything, heck, he risked his licence by saying he was texting! But he was very quick to call this other person and tell her/him something interesting…Now, I’m also not sure what was it that this person “wasn’t going to believe in” – was it that he saw some magic (which excuse me, but I highly doubt, that ball of fire was hardly visible from behind of Rumple’s hand! especially at that car speed!) OR that he saw Rumple or Hook and that was what was so interesting? Maybe he was looking for one of them for ages?
I think Greg was very purposefully looking for SB. I think “Her” knows what he was searching for. So his, “You’ll never believe what I saw,” was along the lines of, “I found them, we were right!” That could play into him having been from a magical land, and once he was in our world, he was seeking out magic here. Depending on who he was, where he was, and when he came back to our world, he may have even had knowledge of the curse, and that could be the reason he was trying to track everyone down.
Like EvilQueen, I also felt Greg knew way more than he let on to Emma, as evidenced when he spoke with HER on the phone. I don’t think anything random happens on this show, and I don’t think he’s just some “average Joe’ as Emma said to her parents. I agree that it’s most likely the case that Greg has been deliberately searching for Storybrooke for a long time, and when the curse broke, he seized the opportunity to trace the magic. Like Phee, I took his “You’ll never believe what I just saw” as confirmation that he was reporting back to HER. Maybe he was confirming that he’d found magic or magical characters. I think they’re both from another land, but they somehow ended up in our land, on the other side of the SB boundary. They want to get to SB though because they want to find a way home.
@TheGoldenKey wrote:
Well here’s what I find rather odd. All his outgoing calls are from Pennsylvania, some as inland as Erie. Yet all his pictures show him on the east coast. Doesn’t make any sense. So, we have NO area codes or numbers linking him to the coastline nor do they show him travelling from Pennsylvania to Maine.
As I was getting towards the end of the list, searching the codes, I thought, “Please let one be from outside PA, just to mix it up.” I did find it interesting that the final one is for “New Castle”. All the others had a compass bearing, but that one just straight up said “Pittsburgh, New Castle”. If we’re thinking he is from Pittsburgh, because that’s where the repeated number is from, then it’s interesting to see that paired up with “New Castle.” New monarch? New ruler of a new land? We have a Newcastle here in Australia, but it’s all the one world, so it stuck out to me that the PA one is spelled as two separate words, especially when castles are kind of a thing on this show.
The reference to New Castle and there being a monarch would fit nicely with my theory that HER stands for Her Evil Royalty (a reference to the band HIM when on tour in the USA). If Greg serves an evil monarch, as I suspect he may, his reporting to a phone number associated with the word castle could be a big hint in that direction.
Phee wrote: My fave theory right now for this guy is the Wizard theory, which would fit quite well, if he’s someone from our world, who has interacted with a magical land, then come back, and is searching to find a remnant of a magical land in our world. In such a scenario, I’m imagining that “Her” is Dorothy, because she’d be someone who has had similar experiences to him, and would understand his current mission, so they’d make a good pair IMO.
I really like the theory of Greg being the professor who ended up as the Wizard of Oz. However, I’d wager that HER might refer to some evil ruler rather than Dorothy. By calling HER “honey” it would be very interesting if the “wizard” and the evil ruler he serves have a romantic relationship of convenience, sort of like Rumple and Cora did at one point. While the wizard is traditionally, a “nice guy” he did lie to everyone in Oz about being “great and all-powerful.” His agenda may in fact be to learn the art of magic from Rumple. The fact that the “wizard” of Oz didn’t have actual magic may have made him obsessed with acquiring it. Perhaps the ruler he serves is actually a witch, who was without magic while stranded in our world, but could sense it when Rumple brought it over (similar to how the BF confirmed she could feel magic’s presence in SB in 2×1).
Phee wrote:
EvilQueen wrote: Something else that stroke me as odd. From the pictures he’s supposedly visiting the coast. Yet all pics of his meal are beef and no seafood. No lobster, crab, fish????
It’s super blurry on the screencap, and I hadn’t originally noticed it when I was making them, but up the top right corner it seems to say “2 weeks ago”, so those pics may not have been taken on his east coast trip.
For argument’s sake, let’s say that the photos were taken on his trip from PA to Maine. PA is landlocked except for Lake Erie to the west and the Delaware River to the east. All the photos featuring Greg actually support a sea-themed trip up the coast. There is actually an obvious picture of him in front of a seafood restaurant that lists several items found on the coast, including lobster, crab, and shellfish. In fact, all this seafood listed makes me wonder if he isn’t from under the sea! Could he be a merman? 💡
TheGoldenKey wrote: Found the statue in the first pic. It’s part of a collection in Steveston BC, the fictional town of Storybrooke. You’ve got the old fisherman tending his nets, the young tenderman unloading his catch and the female canner out on her break. I guess they have no real significance other than to emphasize he’s on a sightseeing trip.
Thanks for that little nugget of gold! The fisherman seems to corroborate the notical theme of him being from “under the sea” origionally and then having been stranded in our world when the curse hit. Maybe he wasn’t stranded in SB, but instead traveled by sea to our world though an underwater portal!
In fact, all the pictures of Greg suggest an ocean theme: the seafood restaurant, the harbor, and the seaman! Of course, the photos could just be further confirmation that he was in fact traveling up the Eastern seaboard on his way to ME and took lots of pictures, rather then a hint that he himself is from the sea.
I adore this theory, but that could be because I’m desperate for some merfolk on this show already! 😉 But considering this, plus the comment someone made earlier about him eating NO SEAFOOD…. Well, he wouldn’t if he were a merman, right? ‘Cause those would be his friends. Secondly, do we know if/where the “line” is under the sea? We saw Cora and Hook appear in a boat, and obviously Storybrooke is on the coast which begs the question if those magical creatures in the sea might be more free to move about than those on land.
Mermaids, of course. Dracula, since Frankenstein was fairly successful. Oz would be lovely. They could tie in Oz and Mary Poppins relatively easily.
Hercules (Greek Mythology).
I can’t believe no ones mentioned Cheshire Cat! He is my absolute favorite animal-character. He could be such fun in Storybrooke! Another nemesis to Gold/Rumple.
