Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Maybe Bae changed his name here as well, i doubt with him returning to EF, he would keep the name Bae, and doubt he would announce to everyone he was the dark one son, so maybe in this AU, Rumple never knew Bae was there and died, like they never knew the relation btw Bae and Rumple.
[adrotate group="5"]"I offended you with my opinion? Ha, you should hear the ones I keep to myself".
MRJ birthday is on 24th december, this year we have a online birthday card, you dont need to log in anything if you want to sign it, here it is.
http://www.groupcard.com/c/_uPeEoqlr65
"I offended you with my opinion? Ha, you should hear the ones I keep to myself".
In other words, they wrote line intending it to refer to Lily, but actress availability prevented them from being able to expand upon it. That’s my guess, at least.
The actress is pretty much available, she doesnt work in a long time, she was a mother in the beggining of the year and before that she doesnt have any work since OUAt, she had a show aired after ouat epis, but the show was filmed before her work on Ouat, so since 2015 she doesnt have projects.
"I offended you with my opinion? Ha, you should hear the ones I keep to myself".
MRJ has never said no to them. When they needed Neal, they got him.
This is different,MRJ went one time,if he had been in more epis than 512, i could agree that he really loves everyone and would return everytime they ask him, but like he said after, he did 512 to give the character a end, a closure for fans to know Neal was happy( even tho he was dead), he could totally refuse now, bc he was not going there to do what could have been and then still be death and unlike Sean not even appear in other epis. Even Sean said in interviews, he said if was to do flashback he would not go, he was going to do in order to give OQ fans closure and have a actual story, that appears will be in 5 epis
"I offended you with my opinion? Ha, you should hear the ones I keep to myself".
@Slurpeez , Adam is right, he didnt said no NVL, he said no darlings. He would still have gone to NVL, bc on 304 was shown that Pan wanted to take him there, so maybe there was no magic bean here and Pan simply took Bae there and then some centuries after, maybe Hook took him to EF? Or the shadow took him there.
@RG good idea, just one problem, would be illogical to fans, Neal alibe and not brought back to SB and RH brought back, also, if Neal was away in some kingdom business, with the king and queen dead im sure he would have to return, they wanted to avoid the issues of fans asking why not Neal in SB and only RH, but like i said if the 610 was the end of the Au then would be fine, but it wont, like i said with them saying they wanted MRJ to return to film some SF scenes, my only thing is he said no, so they had to arrange something.
"I offended you with my opinion? Ha, you should hear the ones I keep to myself".
I say, MRJ probably said no to this bad fan fiction and toxic fandom, bc adam said that they had a story thought for Neal in this au and I like how he almost says Emma and Neal are meant to be in every version of the show, now shut up before I get even more annoyed
no. His alternate history got him to present day Emma by a different route
— Adam Horowitz (@AdamHorowitzLA) December 7, 2016
also adam said Neal never meet the darlings in this version,
"I offended you with my opinion? Ha, you should hear the ones I keep to myself".
Also, if Henry had been born out of wedlock in the Enchanted Forest, he would have been stigmatized as illegitimate, not honored as a knight of the realm or an heir to the throne.
Well, it is Emma’s wish-world, anything goes I assume. But even if it wasn’t, while we have heard the titles Kings and Queens, we’ve never been shown how their titles are passed. Legitimacy may only an issue if the paternity is unknown *and* relevant to a child’s status. Maternity is not in question, and the mother is a princess. It would be different if a woman was claiming to have gotten pregnant by royalty (like Cora). And, unless Neal Jr is around – and males are first-in-line, then Emma is next-in-line for the Throne(s). (Who’s kingdom are the ruling, and who is the reigning Monarch anyways? Snowing’s Kingdom, or James’ Kingdom? Or both?). I don’t know why in Emma’s fantasy world – outside of want to wish herself been widowed by Neal (which makes no sense, wouldn’t you rather he be alive, even if just for the sake of your son?) – why she would wish for that world to follow archaic beliefs around child-legitimacy that she certainly doesn’t subscribe to herself?
Very easy answer, bc unlike Sean, They didn’t get the actor.
Also, if this is the wish from the birthday day, was never about being savior was about probably not be alone , wanting to be with her parents, and never gave up her son, this wish on the pilot, was a empathetic wasn’t Neal biggest fan, yet on Season 1 she made up a fairy tale story to Henry how his father died a hero when he was a firefighter, do in a way this AU fits into pilot Emma feelings, also if Hook Will show up old, with long beard and long white hair, Will fit into Emma description of how did seen hook on her mind based on Disney movies, and would fit into Rumple she meet s1 , how she didn’t trust him, reason, why no zelena, belle, hook on this 1st au, she didn’t meet them in s1. Her wish in pilot was never about savior,was about being alone.
"I offended you with my opinion? Ha, you should hear the ones I keep to myself".
Interesting fact, not that counts for anything , but Secrets and lies even tho had 0.7 ratings Demo, managed to have more viewers than OUAT, at 9 they had 3.28 million and at 10 they had 3.49 million, and usually is the opposite, OUAT as always more viewers than S&L. I know the viewers don`t count , is demo that counts, but i thought was interesting share this fact.
"I offended you with my opinion? Ha, you should hear the ones I keep to myself".
@RG people on set say that Hook on AU mode that meets Emma and is with August say that he is fully old pirate, mode, long hite hair and white beard. Mnay now are saying that the ring is probably august to emmain the au, but i say is too modern and the box is also 2 modern to be on AU. May not be cs proposal, baut maybe is from 612, hook showing the ring to charming asking his premission, i still say the ring is the easy answer, is CS
"I offended you with my opinion? Ha, you should hear the ones I keep to myself".
I stopped following the filming, and I might stop watching the show. It has come to the point that I can’t even enjoy season 1 anymore.
i got to that point on 315, i dont even know here the blu rays of the s1 and s2, i cant see old epis knowing what will happen, tho have to say saw one or other epi, mostly to mock with some friends, have to say i give my thoughts, bc no oen will shut me up of saying what i think, with respect obvious, funny, is that i dont seeing get more right things about the show than the ones seeing, lol.
If only i had this luck with lottery numbers."I offended you with my opinion? Ha, you should hear the ones I keep to myself".
