Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
If Neal is dead, wouldn’t it be a bit more emotional. Or literally would all the characters been there done that. Oh yeah Neal died been down that route before. No biggie so who is the new baddie, wicked witch you say. And if Henry’s is upset that his father had died, why is Hook the one talk to him (unless its force bonding time)Not his Grandfather, not his mother, not his other mother, not his other grandmother. It makes no sense for everyone to say lets just let Hook go talk with him? Sorry if not his mothers, then should be Charming job who also lost his mother and father and is the closets male father figure to Henry. So right not. I’m not saying its Neal. Neal maybe in trouble, he may even be hurt, but I just need more substance to say its Neal.
I have been through character’s death before. But my problem, is If Neal death used as cataylst for CS and Hook/Henry bonding. (which could be viewed as slap in the face to CaptainFire/Swanfire Fans) that is where I would be disappointed. Because the story is telling you that Emma loved Neal and only way it could work for CS is Neal is dead? IF CS is “true love” there is no need for Neal to die, no need for Henry to lose a parent over. Or Rumple to lose a son, Or Emma to lose a love.There is no need to killed Neal second chance at happiness in service to another to find their happiness. It literally makes no sense to me in a story perspective. Basically the Neal dying would leave me with okay so now he is dead now, really, that was pointless. Could left him dead in S2 instead of all that talk of second chances, and hope and blah, blah, blah. Or you know what you could have let him move on with Tamara and she be a sweet loving wife (just saying). I just really have difficult time believing it Neal because it really just seem like a waste and that his story is suddenly cut off and empty. OR someone just seriously had a massive case of back space and decided lets change the story this way.
If Neal is the one to die, then I seriously believe because MRJ asked to leave for what ever personal reasons. I can’t see any of this being story driven without it seeming like its fan pandering and fan service, which is just sad if it is. I’m still keeping my hope that Neal is still alive until proven otherwise.
[adrotate group="5"]"I will be kind but I will speak my mind."
I’m not jumping to conclusions just yet, from just one episode being filmed.I’m still holding on to hope
"I will be kind but I will speak my mind."
whispers don’t you worry, don’t you worry child, see heaven got a plan for you. Its just another day of filming, lets not panic. We don’t know what is going on. Give it a few days of filming before jumping over the proverbial cliff.
"I will be kind but I will speak my mind."
I have never ever heard one bad thing about MRJ not one thing, the cast all say they love him because he is the sweetest and nicest person on the set. Remember the bowl of soup joke was centered around MRJ and welcoming him to team. I can give less care about facebook page and twitter page because I am convince its just an intern who has way to much power on their hand .
"I will be kind but I will speak my mind."
My theory is that the bad things if Pan was tracking Neal to track Emma to track the heart of the truest believer through some sort of blood magic is perhaps Emma and Neal would have been Killed and the Darling boys would have taken baby Henry. We all know that Darling boys knew of Henry because they were going to adopt the child in Save Henry.
So here is a question. Was August being guided by the side of good or for the side of bad. I can see Blue wanting Emma to go jail to ensure that Henry would be safely tuck away in SB, the town that doesn’t exist in a land without magic. I can see Pan wanted Emma to go to jail, perhaps told the Darling boys to tip the cops off, so in the long run they can adopt the child but still Mr. Gold beat them to it. Who was providing August with his info, because I have the inclination that August was not working by himself that night. Questions, Questions, Questions.
"I will be kind but I will speak my mind."
I agree I liked this page because its seems to be free of the shipping wars and its well contained. The mods are great at defusing the situation. And I generally love the chat area where we can have fun and enjoy each other as Oncers, all shipping aside. Honestly I just miss the mirth, warmth, and humor of S1 we all shared, the bowls of soup and the my peach jokes. I loved for us to try and focus on that at least in chat. We can keep all the other stuff to our respective threads.
Big hugs to all Oncers!
"I will be kind but I will speak my mind."
Rumplegirl that is wishful thinking on some they want to dehumanize a character by saying he has no purpose or point to the plot which is farthest from the truth. Nealfire story is so interwove in the plot since S1, he is the reason for the curse, he is Emma’s love, he is Henry’s father, etc etc. He is now connected to various people throughout the story, beyond the core 6. Mulan, Aurora, Phillip, Robin, Peter Pan, Tink, Blue Fairy, Hook to name a few. Neal storyline with Mulan and Robinhood was well played and well written. His storyline with his father in Nasty Habits marvelous.
“That’t why I didn’t coat the tip.” Come on that was BAMF right there. Neal rocks, MRJ rocks, haters to the left. Nasty Habits one of the best episodes of S3."I will be kind but I will speak my mind."
