Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
@steliokontos1 wrote:
That would make sense, the deal that was made between Blue, Geppetto, and Pinocchio would certainly be something that all those involved would rather remain unknown. For Pinocchio to disclose the information he did to Emma with his story was almost a a last ditch effort to get Emma to believe. Even with what he did say he hasn’t yet revealed everything. When he actually does tell Emma and the whole deal gets revealed that’ll be a conversation I really look forward to seeing.[/quote]
So not only will August have some explaining to do to Emma, but Snow I could only imagine would have some choice words for Gepetto and TBF… yikes! Yall saw how she’s been taking people out lately… I would not want to be them when the *ish* hits the fan!
[adrotate group="5"]@sariebelle wrote:
I am probably going way out on a limb here but have any of you considered that he could be Robin Hood? I will say that I do feel he probably is Baelfire, but the stealing aspect (even though it wasn’t exactly from the rich to give to the poor) made me think of Robin Hood. Just a thought.
Robin Hood and Peter Pan to have oddly similar garb – add a feather and some bows and arrows… tada!
I didn’t think of that BUT… that is an interesting perspective also!
I think my original thought was maybe that he wrote it with August’s help… but now that I’m reading some of the theories on the Blue Fairy I could see that as an option as well.
I’m not so sure about Regina writing it, interesting as it is. She didn’t know who August was… or the story of how Emma broke away from the curse, right?! Then again, August added his story to the book… which again, makes me wonder if the Blue Fairy had written it, why wasn’t Pinocchio’s story included? Is it because they weren’t supposed to know he took the second spot in the Enchanted Tree? That can’t be the only reason… whereas if August was somehow connected I could see why maybe he omitted his story until absolutely necessary.
I definitely agree with the current theory of Bae/Neal/PP… have since last season. A lot of what I’m seeing just affirms it.
Does anyone out there think that Neal wrote the book? He’s in NYC, is it too far fetched of me to say that he is a writer (lots of writers in NYC). I’ve been re-watching episode 1 of Season 2 for clues in the opening scene with Neal… including the song playing “Charley’s Girl” by Lou Reed.
Just wanted to see if any of you were wondering the same or had an theories!
