[rumbelledearie]

Well we might not know what Bobby’s up to but I’m super excited to see Emilie filming so much!!! Especially since it’s Belle with Snow, Charming, Emma and Tink – looks like she’s much more involved with the group as an individual without Rumple being with her. Finally!! 🙂

[rumbelledearie]

If it’s all about story, then it has to be Belle who dies. She has no connection to anyone other than Gold, her friends like Archie and Ariel are non-regulars, she gets generally very little screen time and no story…………and the biggie? Her death would IMO lead to Gold having psychic break, a nervous breakdown….He’d be emotionally shattered and deeply, deeply despairing.

I feel like Belle dying and how Gold/Rumple would handle that has already been done though (not that she’s not still a possibility for the death). We’ve already seen Rumple lose (or so he thought) Belle and he lived with that for the 28+ years. That wouldn’t be interesting to tell again, in my opinion. Same with Neal – we’ve already been through the “Neal is dead” thing and seen the fall out. So if it’s about the story then neither Belle nor Neal dying would be anything groundbreaking or unexpected.

They’re both still possibilities though. I just feel like if that’s the route A&E are taking then it’s been done on the show before and not very clever lol.

[rumbelledearie]

One thing I keep seeing is that we are assuming that whoever dies is not getting a happy ending. However,everyone has to die at some point and if they have a brave, noble death possibly fighting evil and protecting those they love, then that is a good ending for their life. Those left behind will be affected no matter what, but like Prince Charming says, “Happy Endings aren’t always what we expect.” (not sure if I have the quote 100% right, but the general idea).

Good point. Going by that logic and studying the characters, I think Belle’s happy ending is with Rumple, Neal’s happy ending is with Emma and Henry (or having a family and a home), and Hook’s would be to return to the hero he once was – he used to be valiant and in the Navy. I think a happy ending for Hook would be to become selfless again and be reunited with Milah.

Hook seems most likely but it’s still a close call between him and Neal :-/

[rumbelledearie]

Also, Bobby is in 312….,he definitely filmed something for that It’s amazing how Adam/Eddy have managed to squelch any enthusiasm I had for the show. Gold is dead. He’s dead. I don’t understand the Persephone/Hades comparison because that hardly has a happy ending; she’s stuck with him for half the year and then she gets to go back to Earth. Is the implication that Belle could strike a deal where she could visit Gold in the Underworld (Hell?) for 6 months a year? Ouch, what a brutal storyline

Wait I missed something – where did we hear that Bobby was in 312 and 315???? That would be awesome lol, but were there pics/confirmation or is that just speculation??

[rumbelledearie]

I just don’t see a HEA for all the characters when Adam and Eddy specificially said that not all the characters would be getting happy endings………and I don’t think they were misleading us; I think they were very serious

Coconut in fire made the BF come back to life. (rolls eyes) They wrote themselves into a corner by saying dead is dead and then not sticking to it. However this is one case where I’m ok with it

The BF wasn’t dead, though, not really – she just had her shadow removed. Here, Eddy has come right out and said that Gold is dead. Yes, he then said he saw the dagger go into him, implying that he merely thinks he must be dead, assuming it, but his first words were to say “he’s dead”. Of course I don’t want Gold to be dead, but apparently he is and now they’re going to have to resurrect him in some way. I have no idea why they didn’t just go with the “his sacrifice saved him” bit which I had assumed. It’s like his sacrifice was no big deal to Adam/Eddy

I don’t know how reliable IMDB is, but Robert Carlyle was only listed on the show for 2011-2013 and now they changed it to 2011-2014, and he’s not listed under the early episodes for 3B but he’s listed as Rumpelstiltskin/Mr. Gold for Episode 316! Rumple comes back!

Emilie and Colin are also listed for 316 but not MRJ 🙁

[rumbelledearie]

He better not really be dead. With all of this speculation about whether Belle, Neal or Hook will die, I would have to consider not watching if Belle died. But if Rumple is really gone from the show? Then I’d definitely stop watching. So I hope that by Eddy adding that last part “it looked like death to me, but he’s the Dark One”, that’s a hint that he’s coming back.

[rumbelledearie]

I feel like if Belle were to die I’d seriously consider not watching, mainly because Rumbelle is the reason I got hooked on the show in the first place. Not that I don’t love the other characters, Neal and Emma (individually as well as together), but Rumple and Belle really got me hooked emotionally to the show. So if one of them were to die I’d consider not watching anymore. But I really don’t see it being her.

I’ll be VERY disappointed if it’s Neal, I love his storyline (not the triangle) and I really want to see how his relationship with Rumple progresses. But I wouldn’t stop watching if he were the one to go.

Hook is the character I’d be the least upset about (although I really love Colin). He’s definitely entertaining and fun to watch but there hasn’t been enough to grab me emotionally as far as his storyline. It would still be sad though as he’s a colorful character and they could do more with him than some triangle (same for Neal and Emma).

[rumbelledearie]

As much as I hate to say it, it’s most likely Neal. I can’t see Colin being so unhappy. The people who have the most reasons to be unhappy are Emilie and MRJ, but it sounds like Emilie’s been filming a lot lately, with the Belle-centric episode and Vancity tweeted today that Emilie was filming, and A&E said that Emilie’s been giving them some of her best stuff lately.

As much as I love SF and Neal, I think MRJ is the most likely to be unhappy with his storyline.

[rumbelledearie]

He’s perfect!

I figured we’d see him in flashbacks with a younger Belle or something but in Keck’s other tweet he tells him to have fun filming with Emilie AND Bobby.  So maybe it’s not just in flashback? Rumple wasn’t there when Belle was younger. (That would make it a little creepy lol)

After all, in Beauty and the Beast, Lumiere was with the beast in his castle the whole time, not with Belle when she was younger. She doesn’t meet Lumiere til she goes to the castle and meets the beast. Maybe wherever Rumple ends up, he runs into Lumiere?

[rumbelledearie]

Also, I’m not 100% convinced that they will be separated for 11 episodes (I know we’ve disagreed on this) but I sorta think that by 315 Belle will have found Rumple and then they have to fight their way back to SB.

Do you really think so? I was convinced they would meet up again soon because of that interview where Adam and Eddy said that they would be together in the second half, but I just re-read it and they said “they’ll be in the same world”, not *together* in that world, and “their relationship will be explored no matter what state it’s in”, which could mean just through flashbacks as the “state” of their relationship is separated.

I really want to see them together again soon. And I want to see Rumple back soon as he’s the main reason I watch and it’ll be kinda boring for me until he returns lol.

[Author]

Posts