Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
I don’t think it’s Rumple. My first guess was that August took a turn for the worse or something
The first photo that Obisgirl posted appears to be in the Apprentice’s house, actually.
Which is why I was thinking August. That was his last location. Plus, Blue being there?
ETA: wait. August is IN that photo. Nevermind. As you were.
[adrotate group="5"]"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"I don’t think it’s Rumple. My first guess was that August took a turn for the worse or something
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"Unless, as someone theorized on this thread, Outlaw Regina interrupts the wedding and RH elopes with her, à la Charming and Snow.
That’s a big possibility. I just have to wonder how that fits in the whole “role reversal” situation of heroes and villains. Because the villain Regina would be getting her HEA but hero Robin would also be getting his HEA.
Maybe that’s why the Author is really there (he’s in the throne room of Snowing at one point…but in his 1960s clothes…)? He gives Rumple want Rumple wants but then inserts himself into the story to change things to his own liking–Isaac does seem to be a bit overly fond of Regina.
*brain pain* Seriously. What does Isaac even *want*? Is it just a good story? #ShadyAuthor
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"Who’s the Dark One now then? Or is Rumple still going to be the D1, but make better decisions about how to use (instead of abuse) his powers? Perhaps the Dark One title has changed to the ‘light one’? It’ll be interesting to see how Zelena’s life is in this new world. I’m also curious to see how Robin’s life is in the alt-reality. Will his ‘goody-ness’ be switched with the sheriff’s ‘baddie-ness’ I wonder (now wouldn’t that be a kick in the teeth for Regina!).
I think in Rumple’s HEA (if that’s what we’re witnessing on some level) the Dark One’s curse isn’t a thing at all and he’s the Light One–or at least a very valiant knight.
As for RH, I dunno. He seems to be taking on Prince Charming’s role (they even have Sean dressed in some of Josh’s old clothes) but instead of finding Regina he ends up marrying Zelena so he is denied his HEA. But he’s not necessarily a villain like Snow and Charming.
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"So does baby Neal exist in this AU or have they just completely forgotten about him?
I don’t think he exists
I’m still unclear on the rules of how his writing works — can he manipulate everything, or are there limits?
To add to this: why isn’t the Sorcerer stopping all this, if the Sorcerer is out God-insert. Does he think there is a lesson to be learned on both sides and thus lets it play out? Does he need Emma to do her Stabby POOF thing in the end so he’s letting this happen to ensure that?
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"I’d say it’s pretty certain, yes.
Okay, but based on what? In the show, all we have to go on is Zelena’s word, and she’s not exactly known for her honesty and trustworthiness.
Well the fact that no one is doubting her–Regina or Robin or even Emma (of the wonky super power)–is leading me to believe that there was some Off Screen-ville action in which something was done to test the legitimacy of said pregnancy. We went from “she’s pregnant” to Robin and Regina sitting in a bar and talking about it, so I assume something was done to test for baby and Zelena was not found to be lying
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"Zelena really is pregnant but won’t be raising her child. It sounds like Robin and Regina will be, with Zelena granted very limited contact. How do you feel about this solution?
Is it certain that the pregnancy is for real? Zelena could still be lying about being pregnant, since Regina didn’t make her pee on a stick or anything.
I’d say it’s pretty certain, yes.
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"*blinks*
Did I miss something? Why is Milah coming back? Why would she be coming back? She’s never even mentioned. Like…every time they have a chance to mention her they do this magnificent dance around the Milah issue. It’s almost masterful.
I mean, it’s A and E so they COULD in theory but…would they? Nope.
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"
