Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Ok Snowing parallel, remember when Snow woke David up from his coma in the first season and she had to look on helplessly as he hugged his “wife.” Who else got flashback syndrome after Nealfire got free and Hook was seeing them hug?
[adrotate group="5"]
“I never thought I’d be capable of letting go of my first love, of my Milah. To believe that I could find someone else, that is until I met you”.
That’s it I’m dead by feels!!!!!
See, this is something I’ve always wondered about – is True Love itself a conscious choice? Snowing chose to be with each other, to find each other whatever the cost. That was their conscious choice, that was them giving everything they had of themselves to the other, and that’s what made it True. And then we have Rumbelle – who we know are a TL couple, BUT, I don’t think that Rumple has completely chosen to… let it take over, if you know what I mean. When Belle first kissed him, the Dark One curse started to fade away – but then Rumple made a conscious decision to reject that love. We know that TL can break any curse, so every time Rumbelle kiss the Dark One curse should break. But it doesn’t. And we can also establish that Rumbelle don’t have a psychic connection as he didn’t know she was alive when Regina held her captive. I believe Rumple is “at fault” here – he hasn’t given everything he is to Belle, hasn’t let his “essence” intermingle with Belle’s completely. That’s just my opinion though.
i think that depends on what you believe some people believe that love is a choice we choose who we love. Other people see it as something involuntary that just happens. Rumple’s problem is the same as it’s always been since he lost Bae through the portal. He in this conflict with himself about choosing his power over the ones he loves. I think he was doing better when it comes to letting Belle in but I mean it’s clear he hasn’t opened himself up completely, he’s not ready to give up his magic
I can see how people would think that but I don’t see it that way. I want her to make a conscious choice. I want her to struggle over letting him in, letting down her walls completely to him. I want to see both of them come to depend on each other emotionally, and in all other ways. I don’t want to see Emma’s “choice” being made in the form of TLK. I really don’t, because the writers have emphasised to us so much Emma’s choice has been taken away from her so many times, and that she hates that. And TLK would be another way of taking away her conscious choice. Ugh, the thought of Neal and Killian queuing up over her cursed body to kiss her – just ugh. UGH. I don’t like it. Sorry, that’s just my opinion…. Anyway choice is a CS theme – “I’d pick you” “You chose her”. To solve her TL dilemma via curse would be completely taking away from that theme, which I don’t believe the writers will do.
I can can see it from your point of view too, I guess I had been seeing the sleeping curse as Emma making the ultimate choice of sacrifice just like Snow and Henry did. Emma would have to give herself up to the curse for it to work. (I also have this Peter Pan as the Sandman theory things would sort of fit nicely with). For whatever reason she makes the conscious choice to accept the curse. To me having Emma’s curse only broken by one of them says that even if the hadn’t admitted it to each other that they have chosen each other. The kiss is dependent on them choosing each other as their true love at that point all doubt would basically be removed.
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO. This is not what I want for her. I want her to make the choice. Maybe that’s just me?? I’ve seen this thought floating around before and i really dislike it. Now, AFTER she makes the choice i’d be happy for a curse to be broken via TLK, because we know who’ll break it hehe. But not before she chooses.
but if only one of them can break it doesn’t that kind of say that she is choosing to love one over the other? For the kiss to work the feeling has to be mutual right? That’s why I like it because both Neal and Hook care about Emma but for the kiss to work only the one she loves can save her.
I had this interesting thought I wanted to run by my fellow shipmates. What if Pan forces Emma into a sleeping curse which as we know requires true love’s kiss to break. So then at that point either Hook or Neal’s kiss will be what saves her?!
