Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Actually Lana said that Lana knew about it, and used that information to fuel her scenes with Robin. Regina didn’t know.
Oh, is that what she said- I stand corrected then. However it doesnt change Emma going back in time & finding out about Regina murdering Robin’s wife- even if she hadnt rescued Marian, the truth would have eventually come out- Carrying a secret like that would have eaten Emma up, she would have at least had to confide in Snow/Charming or Regina. So one way or the other, the truth would have come out eventually, at least this way Marian is alive & kicking, so the worst thing Regina did was throw her in prison, which is still waaaaay more forgivable than murder IMO 😉
[adrotate group="5"]Favorite CS moment?? That’s almost impossible because I have so many! The S3 finale kiss at Granny’s is a big one because it was such a “FINALLY!!” moment. I also loved the whole past Hook sequence in S3 E21/E22. Mainly because I think it showed how Emma was able to acknowledge the feelings she had for Hook as HOOK all along. And even though Capt. Hook was supposed to be this fearsome and dangerous pirate (even in Killian’s mind), he was never a danger to Emma. They were ALWAYS meant to be together, they are timeless – they were always meant to bring the best out of each other. They can be themselves with each other, they don’t have to pretend to be someone they aren’t. Even though they both WANT to be the best version of themselves for each other, they really never HAD to be – the growth/redemption they went through was really for themselves as individuals. They really recognized they were meant for each other from the very beginning when Emma still had her walls sky high and Killian was still deeply in the midst of revenge as Capt. Hook but they weren’t ready as individuals yet to go there. But I think my very favorite CS scenes are more subtle. They are the scenes when Killy is building Emma up when she is losing her confidence or when when Killy gets to be the strong one. Like when Emma wasn’t sure they would be able to #saveHenry and Killy gave her the “I’ve yet to see you fail” speech that left her breathless and speechless. And when she gave her leadership speech on the beach in Neverland about how they all needed to work together and Regina seemed a bit peeved but Killy gave Regina this look like “That’s my girl” cause he was so impressed and proud of what Emma had just said. And at the Royal Ball in the EF when Emma doesn’t what to do and Killy shows her how to dance and says the only rule is to pick a partner who knows what he’s doing. And when Emma cries watching Snow try on her future wedding ring and Killy tells her it’s alright because not everyone gets to watch their parents fall in love. But I think there is currently a tie for my all time favorite CS moment. First: the expression on Killian’s face when he says “Looks like we are back on track then, love” and wipes her tears away after Snow doesn’t recognize her after Blue turns her back into a human from a bug. Colin is a master at facial expressions. The best part about this scene is he makes you remember that he knows EXACTLY how she feels. He was SO happy to see Emma when he found her in New York but she looked at him and had no idea who he was. So even though he was heart-broken about that, the fact that he had found her meant that he was on track. So that scene collectively shows the heartbreak they BOTH went through at having someone they deeply love not even recognize them. But Killian didn’t have anyone to comfort him! He knows EXACTLY how to comfort Emma and what she needs to hear. It shows how perfect they are for each other. Second: the expression on Killy’s face when Emma tells him that Storybrooke is her home and he tells her to look down. One of the things I love best about CS is that from the very beginning they figured out they were equals because they went on an adventure together that required both of their knowledge and skill. And here you can see just how PROUD Killy is of Emma that she is strong enough to have figured out what she needed to get her magic back all on her own. He KNEW she could do it and she DID. Once again, Colin and his amazing acting. I don’t know, I think this one might be my favorite.
LOL, some of my fav scenes are in this post, but I still cant pick which is my fav 😉
Ellemo I look forward to hearing what your fav moment/s is/are- I’ll be watching this weekend & post mine then as well 🙂
Hehe POM, it still puts a smile on my face every time I read you complement Killy, I glad he won someone over on this site 🙂
Robin would have thought Marian’s death was on him, and said nothing else of it, and OutlawQueen would be in “Problem Free/Always Adventurous Zone”.
I believe Lana confirmed that Regina did know she killed Robin’s wife (before Emma went back in time). So I highly doubt Robin would have forgiven her for murdering his wife & the mother of his only child, had he found out & tbh it would make Regina seem like she hadnt really changed all that much if she didnt confess to him it was HER fault Marian was dead- after all if you truly love someone you dont just let them go on believing they are responsible for the death of their loved one, when you know full well they are not- esp if it was you that did the killing! :/
I agree that now in the altered timeline, Regina never murdered Marian, so she doesnt have the actual memory of murdering her, only of locking her up with intention of murdering her- Both Marian & Emma know that EQ was going to murder her, so for them it is still “reality”. In fact bringing her to the future may have given OQ a chance it may not have otherwise had when the truth came out- Forgiving someone for locking your wife up is one thing, forgiving them for murdering her is another 😉 Which is why, as much as I LOVE OQ, I also agree with much of POM post too (although it was VERY refreshing to see one couple happily in love for a change lol 😛 ).
Good Form ranks very highly on my fav episodes as well ellemo 🙂
Love hearing why people love what they love about the show & yeah, Good form really show cases Colin’s acting skills, he really is right up there with JMo, Lana, Robbie & co with his emotional acting skill levels- he has that something extra going on 🙂
I wonder what everyone’s fav CS moment is?
I’ll have to do a rewatch of my 4 fav parts to rank them 😉
Colin & Josh are such big goof balls 😛 I get the feeling that despite the hrs, the Once set must be a fairly nice work environment to be immersed in 16hrs a day 😉
https://twitter.com/SciFiFantasyTV/status/490671956174180353/photo/1
http://mindyourhelm.tumblr.com/post/92237911477/so-the-truth-comes-out-grumpy-is-charmings LOL, god I love our fans with a talent for the humorous 😉 They come up with some of the funniest things for our ship & bromance pairings & I love how we as a ship, can simply have fun & a good laugh over poking fun at both lol 😉
Hahaha, on the marshmallow man 😀
Oh good lord!
LOL- I watch for plot, I … watch… for … plot … I…. Watch… pl…. Damn, we have one hell of a YUMMY cast! 😀 😉 😛 😉 😛 😉
https://twitter.com/Caldude56/status/490311888027152384/photo/1
I don’t think Hook’s going to be Frozen, or that Colin’s going to miss any episodes. I have a feeling there will be zero nods to Olaf (I haven’t seen the movie, so I don’t know if that’s a huge bummer, I’m just going off what A&E have said in interviews…). I think it’s going to be a much more simple, they think Elsa’s bad but it turns out she’s good but oh crud who’s EM cause she’s really bad. The Frozen mini-arc is simply cross promotion between Disney and ABC. And ABC isn’t going to use Colin as one of their ‘faces’ and then let A&E write him out of episode(s).
yep, agreed.
