Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Yes, she would have probably brought Marian back with them anyway even though she shouldn’t have, because that is what that family does. They do things without thinking. She assumed that Marian was going to die because it was pretty set that that was what was going to happen. But she really didn’t know. The only reason she was able to fix the mess she did with her parents was because she new the story and how it went, if she hadn’t she would have messed herself up out of existence. She didn’t know Robin and Marian’s story so she just did what she felt like doing.
Adam and Eddie did an interview in which they state what Robin said happened. That she used to be sick got cured then he lost her anyway and A & E said they will explain how that happened in the coming season. So the question is not would she have still rescued Marian had she known who she was? But, should she have butted into something that she shouldn’t have?
Here’s the link to the interview:
http://insidetv.ew.com/2014/05/12/once-upon-a-time-season-3-finale-postmortem/
[adrotate group="5"]One would think. But have you met Emma Swan? If she doesn’t require a believable post-funeral grieving period, neither would Robin. This show doesn’t have time for that.
In my opinion Emma didn’t really have a grieving period because she no longer loved Neal romantically. She would always love Neal because he was Henry’s dad but she was already falling for Hook by the end of the first half of this season. That is why she was able to move on so quickly, which it really bugs me because if she wouldn’t have been so indecisive maybe Neal wouldn’t have been so desperate to get back to them. He probably would have still tried to get back to Henry but maybe he would have stayed in character and not have made such a rash decision and would of taken his time. All pure ifs but what’s done is done. On to Robin and Marian, seeing it from this point I really wouldn’t know because we haven’t seen what type of relationship they actually have, I guess it would depend if Robin is still very much in love with Marian on whether he would be able to move on faster or not.
I’d rather Robin choose Regina over Marian, because her dying and him choosing Regina would make it seem almost as if he’s settling for Regina! And THE QUEEN is Second to NO ONE! It’s either her or nothing at all….after he chooses Regina…then Marian can politely get thrown off a bridge, or shot from a cannon to Timbuktu!
Nothing personal Marian dear, it’s just no one crosses MY Ship!
Daaamn… No one should mess with you. 🙂
Lol… Poor Marian, shooting her out of a canon and all, but I get you. Love my baby Regina and this is so hurtful. These freakin’ months are going to kill me.
Current tragedy will overcome past tragedy in the season 4 opener when the diner scene resumes and Marian says, in a slurred voice, “I feel funny”. Cut to Dr. Whale explaining to a grieving Robin “She died from a clot at the back of her brain”, and all eyes turn to Emma.
The episode could end with a “This season on Once Upon A Time” preview: Charming lying on a hospital bed, Whale telling Snow “He died from a clot in his brain”; Hook lying on a hospital bed, Whale telling Emma “He died from a clot in his brain”. Any other old head injuries?
I would find this extremely funny? A good way for Emma to learn cause and affect. Did you see the size of that tree branch? But seriously, they need to cut down the head traumas to a minimum. Blood clots are no joke 🙂
They could actually still save it if they clarify the original story from the timeline before it was changed. I keep thinking about it and nothing adds up. Robin first said that Marian died because because he put her in harms way, though she was imprisoned by Regina because as Marian said she new where Snow White was hiding and yet Snow White and Robin Hood had never previously met before being in the Enchanted forest during that lost year that people didn’t remember. Robin couldn’t have meant having Marian with him caused her death because wouldn’t he feel the same way about Roland and yet he still had his son with him. In any case I don’t like triangles and I hope they resolve whether he stays with Regina or not rather quickly. The longer it last the more damage it will cause.
That had completely gone over my head. I would completely be up for that I loved those two. Wow so exciting.
I don’t think she will regress either. I think the biggest change will be Regina’s relationship with Emma. She won’t hate her, but I don’t see her wanting to have anything to do with her after this. No more magic lessons. No more joining their magic to block out the moon. Bridges have been burned. She won’t try to harm her, but it’s going to be a lot of cold shoulders at Henry hand offs.
OMG! Kind of like divorced parents whose marriage ended badly Lol. But yeah I agree no more magic lessons, of course now she has Rumple to teach her. Though I also think Regina might need some lessons herself, you know on account of now being able to use light magic herself. Do you think she will still be able to use light magic now that anger has risen inside her again? o_O”
Nope. Don’t get me wrong I love Rumple and Regina equally. I cry when either one is hurt. Hence my username. But that doesn’t mean I turn a blind eye when they are at fault. Regina might have said those things about what happened to Belle but everyone needs to take responsibility for the actions they take including Rumple. He beat Maurice, Belle’s father. That was his doing, given Maurice is an ass himself and actions where derived from anger Regina caused, Rumple beat Maurice not Regina that was his actions by himself and he hasn’t even apologize for it even now, knowing that it wasn’t true. Everyone gives Regina slack and want her to apologize, which she has actually started to do and where the Heck are his apologies. Also no matter what you say to me I will keep doubt open on if she ever did kill Marian until I actually see it. Sorry not really sorry, it’s called tough love.
Yeah its Regina’s fault that Rumple beat Maurice cus Regina put the cane in his hand. Let’s not let Rumple take responsibility for any of his actions. And technically now Regina didn’t kill Marian where as Rumple still clobbered Maurice.
Yes strongly implied but we never saw it. So it’s now just speculation. I don’t intend to judge her over something that I don’t know. People tend to jump with pitchforks anytime they see an imagine that is out of context let alone something being strongly implied. I watch The Walking Dead and in that show if you don’t see someone die they ain’t dead so I am always questioning. To tell the truth I would rather see Robin with Marian since they have a child together same with Emma and Neal but they killed of Neal so there it is. For me she is hurting right now and that is all that matters. I don’t like triangles which is why I would rather she close him off completely maybe Henry can support her in this coming year now that she knows that she can love again so she does not end up an icicle queen.
