Sarah Chalke: Devon writes: “My drawn-out Once Upon a Time theory is that Neal is also Peter Pan and that Tamara is Tinkerbell or Wendy. Can you help a sister out?”
Matt Mitovich: As far as Neal, I just spoke to Eddy Kitsis and Adam Horowitz (…), and they said that they’ve seen a LOT of theories about Neal out there, probably including the Peter Pan one, they say that they have not seen anyone get it right yet.
I don’t think this necessarily means that Neal is not Pan. I think what it means is that we haven’t guessed at how it all fits in together. Like someone said earlier in the thread, the way they twist these stories maybe quite different than what we are expecting in this case.
[adrotate group="5"]
"We were happy."
"Because... it was born out of true love."