I agree that he was in Neverland for a good long while and that he’s Peter Pan, so the question I really want to explore is how did he get to NYC or who brought him here. My guess is Blue because I think she’s going to stand in for Tinkerbell.
Oh looking at the evidence, I agree. I just say that for the first time, it does not add up, which surprises me. Everything else is so carefully constructed.
And another thing. The bean was supposed to send them to a place without magic. Neverland is not without magic. No one ages for one, I call that pretty magical.