how did Rumple get the shawl when Bae/Neal/Peter Pan was wearing it in Never Never Land? (or do we assume that Rumple was such a broke medieval father than Bae actually had a couple of shawls….!!!)
Bae was wearing his hooded cloak when he went through the portal. The shawl is a different garment he left behind, though seems to be made from similar fabric. By that time, Rumple could whip up and clothes he liked, but I’m guessing that old cloak was something Bae’s mother had made, just like she made the shawl.