5×11“SWAN SONG” FAVORITE & LEAST FAVORITE MOMENTS and DIALOGUE

[RumplesGirl]

We have no sense at all of time passing, but we also have no sense at all of Snow’s (or Charming’s) relationship to their youngest child.

Well said. Snow and Charming heading down to Hades with Emma is also the second time this season that they’ve rushed headlong into death without even pausing to think about their youngest child. The first time was standing up to the Fury in 502. Both times, they’ve decided to die/go on a dangerous mission that would leave their newborn child an orphan. Which, you know, you think would bother them given how it messed up Emma for her entire life.

You get a big ol’ PREACH for everything else you wrote, btw.

[The Swan Princess]

The Swan Princess wrote:

3) Apparently Rumple was literally in hell? To what moment are they referring, when he almost died of Hook’s poison or when he almost died from a heart attack in the hospital in New York? Because I don’t remember him actually dying and not breathing in any of them. But I could be wrong.

I’m pretty sure the writers are referring to Rumple after he stabbed Pan and then went to the Vault of Eternal Goo, but that’s problematic because it’s not the Underworld nor Hell. It’s a Vault. The Underworld appears to be a totally separate realm, not a part from SB, the EF, ect.

Quote

Oh right I forgot about that

I… Don’t understand anything. I don’t think the writers thought this through. I don’t think they thought about anything this arc really.

You know what I can't continue with the dead people brought back to life list I'm out of space in the signature and now we have an underworld arc this is to much I quit why do you bring so many people back to life OUAT WHHHYYYY

[PriceofMagic]

Apparently the bedroom RumBelle were in was supposed to be at their house. However, that makes completely no sense. We saw their bedroom in season 2 and it was much bigger than the one they were in in Swan Song. Even if you said they redecorated, it still wouldn’t work because the whole layout of the room is different eg the windows and doors (stuff which can’t just be moved around.) It also doesn’t make sense that they would just be in a different room in the house because honestly who sleeps in a different bedroom when their bedroom is just down the hall?

All magic comes with a price!

Keeper of Felix

[MatthewPaul]

Apparently the bedroom RumBelle were in was supposed to be at their house. However, that makes completely no sense. We saw their bedroom in season 2 and it was much bigger than the one they were in in Swan Song. Even if you said they redecorated, it still wouldn’t work because the whole layout of the room is different eg the windows and doors (stuff which can’t just be moved around.) It also doesn’t make sense that they would just be in a different room in the house because honestly who sleeps in a different bedroom when their bedroom is just down the hall?

Quote

I recall hearing that the house they used back in Seasons 1-2 was sold, so it became unavailable ever since.

[PriceofMagic]

I recall that as well. They should’ve just thrown in a line about how RumBelle had moved or that was Belle’s place or something instead of just trying to pretend it’s the same house when clearly it’s not the same house.

All magic comes with a price!

Keeper of Felix

[Author]

Posts