ONCE - Once Upon a Time podcast

Reviews, theories, and talk about ABC's Once Upon a Time TV show

  • Home
  • Once Upon a Time
  • Wonderland
  • Forums
    • Recent posts
    • Recent posts (with spoilers)
  • Timeline
  • Live
  • Sponsor
    • Privacy Policy

Ingrid in Our World

Home › Forums › Once Upon a Time › Season Four › 4×10 “Shattered Sight” › Ingrid in Our World

  • This topic has 19 replies, 9 voices, and was last updated 10 years, 5 months ago by lorem ipsum.
Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 20 total)
1 2 →
  • Author
    Posts
  • December 7, 2014 at 9:08 pm #292334
    RumplesGirl
    Keymaster

    I…have confusion

    1) How did Ingrid actually GET into SB? One second she was standing at the line and the next she was just in town.

     

    2) How did Regina not know that some new stranger arrived in her town?

     

    3) How did Ingrid use magic inside SB to take Emma’s memories. Regina’s ring barely worked to make the hat function, so how did the crystal?

    [adrotate group="5"]

    "He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"
    December 7, 2014 at 9:18 pm #292341
    MatthewPaul
    Moderator

    I…have confusion

    1) How did Ingrid actually GET into SB? One second she was standing at the line and the next she was just in town.

    Remember, August got into SB without being a victim of the curse either. So while normal people from A Land Without Magic can’t get into SB, anyone who is originally from FTL can.

    December 7, 2014 at 9:20 pm #292344
    RumplesGirl
    Keymaster
    RumplesGirl wrote:

    I…have confusion 1) How did Ingrid actually GET into SB? One second she was standing at the line and the next she was just in town.

    Remember, August got into SB without being a victim of the curse either. So while normal people from A Land Without Magic can’t get into SB, anyone who is originally from FTL can.

    But she’s not from FTL. She’s from Arendelle (okay, I get what you’re saying…we don’t have a map so it’s hard to know where the boundaries are…but that’s rather fast and loose?)

    "He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"
    December 7, 2014 at 9:23 pm #292346
    MatthewPaul
    Moderator

    But she’s not from FTL. She’s from Arendelle (okay, I get what you’re saying…we don’t have a map so it’s hard to know where the boundaries are…but that’s rather fast and loose?)

    I’d say Arendelle is still in the same realm (FTL), because you only needed to travel by boat, not by portal. It’s the Enchanted Forest/Mist Haven that is the separate part of the world where most of the FTL characters are, but it’s the same realm.

    December 7, 2014 at 9:27 pm #292348
    RumplesGirl
    Keymaster
    RumplesGirl wrote:

    But she’s not from FTL. She’s from Arendelle (okay, I get what you’re saying…we don’t have a map so it’s hard to know where the boundaries are…but that’s rather fast and loose?)

    I’d say Arendelle is still in the same realm (FTL), because you only needed to travel by boat, not by portal. It’s the Enchanted Forest/Mist Haven that is the separate part of the world where most of the FTL characters are, but it’s the same realm.

    No no, I totally get what you’re saying and that is probably how it works, so I’m okay with it (not so much the not having to actually walk across the town line…August did DRIVE over).

     

    Now answer the rest of them….

    "He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"
    December 7, 2014 at 9:34 pm #292350
    MatthewPaul
    Moderator

    2) How did Regina not know that some new stranger arrived in her town?

    3) How did Ingrid use magic inside SB to take Emma’s memories. Regina’s ring barely worked to make the hat function, so how did the crystal?

    2) This was probably an oversight. I guess she just kept incognito to the best of her abilities. Granted she only cared about August because he was talking to Henry, though she was still alarmed when she noticed Kurt and Owen in town.
    3) Most likely you answered your own question. Creating magic from magic. It’s hokey, but it’s not like we didn’t see Regina make a forgetting potion in 309’s flashback and the Dragon using magic outside Storybrooke itself. Though I imagine you have issues with those examples, too.

    December 7, 2014 at 9:40 pm #292353
    RumplesGirl
    Keymaster

    Though I imagine you have issues with those examples, too.

    Only since they deliberately and intentionally showed Ingrid to be magic-less in Boston when she arrived.

    "He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"
    December 7, 2014 at 10:28 pm #292372
    Jiminy’s Journal
    Participant
    RumplesGirl wrote:

    But she’s not from FTL. She’s from Arendelle (okay, I get what you’re saying…we don’t have a map so it’s hard to know where the boundaries are…but that’s rather fast and loose?)

    I’d say Arendelle is still in the same realm (FTL), because you only needed to travel by boat, not by portal. It’s the Enchanted Forest/Mist Haven that is the separate part of the world where most of the FTL characters are, but it’s the same realm.

    Right. Arendelle, Misthaven, and Agrabah, (and possibly “Victorian England”) are all part of FTL, but the curse only took people IN Misthaven (plus Dr. Frankenstein and Jefferson, unless they also ended up in Misthaven somehow — Jefferson could have used the White Rabbit, in theory — granted, this doesn’t explain Regina’s fear that Cora would be taken by the curse, unless she REALLY wanted her dead). All of the magical realms, however, were put in a time haze.

    December 7, 2014 at 10:56 pm #292380
    SirMedraut
    Participant

    2) How did Regina not know that some new stranger arrived in her town?

    This is what vexes me most, because I remembered this and kept waiting for a scene all episode. Must have gotten cut, which is extremely annoying and one of my few complaints about the episode. Regina got involved and interested in visitors like August & Greg, but some non-cursed stranger opens an ice cream shop and she didn’t have anything to say about it?

    Keeper of Zelena's witch hat and the Black Fairy's wand.

    December 7, 2014 at 11:15 pm #292387
    RumplesGirl
    Keymaster
    RumplesGirl wrote:

    2) How did Regina not know that some new stranger arrived in her town?

    This is what vexes me most, because I remembered this and kept waiting for a scene all episode. Must have gotten cut, which is extremely annoying and one of my few complaints about the episode. Regina got involved and interested in visitors like August & Greg, but some non-cursed stranger opens an ice cream shop and she didn’t have anything to say about it?

    Ooooh. I totally forgot about that spoiler. Hmm. scene cut, obviously. But somewhat nice to know that it was addressed

    "He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"
  • Author
    Posts
Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 20 total)
1 2 →

The topic ‘Ingrid in Our World’ is closed to new replies.

Design by Daniel J. Lewis | D.Joseph Design • Built on the Genesis Framework