Missing it…. WHAT EVIDENCE ????

[charming]

@NONNIE wrote:

I DO NOT GET IT… a lot of people in the chat room and on the blogs say… WHY DOES EMMA NOT BELIEVE ??? I do not know what evidence is she suppose to be believing.

A book that contains fairy-tales, folk lore but not necessarily history or logical facts.

Yes, Emma knows Regina is evil, but I am sure in her job as a bounty hunter Emma knew people in the real world that was just as bad and did worse things. ( Remember, she has no way of knowing what occurred in FTL except the book.) She has know way of knowing Regina and EQ are the same person.

What evidence has been presented to her that FTL existed?
What evidence has presented to her that Snow and James are her parents?
What evidence has been presented to her that magic exists?

I just do not get it …. WHY should Emma believe?

Would you believe?

NONNIE
What if someone brought you a copy of the Star War Trilogy and said to you, you are Princess Leia and need to help Luke Skywalker fight the Empire for the Republic. You just have to believe and in two days a starship will come and pick you up and go to the other side of the galaxy. You are our only hope………

.

.

[ms. pixie]

@charming wrote:

What if someone brought you a copy of the Star War Trilogy and said to you, you are Princess Leia and need to help Luke Skywalker fight the Empire for the Republic. You just have to believe and in two days a starship will come and pick you up and go to the other side of the galaxy. You are our only hope………

I would put on my white gown, fetch my blaster and sit on the porch waiting for the starship to show up. :geek:

I agree with you, charming – with the aliens example too! – what does it take to change completely your comprehension of life and the world you live in? A lot, I would say.

[midnight dreary]

@Ms. Pixie wrote:

I would put on my white gown, fetch my blaster and sit on the porch waiting for the starship to show up. :geek:

YOU ARE SO BRILLIANTLY AWESOME!!!!! 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 I just had to come in here and say that. 😀

[true believer]

I guess everyone is just getting frustrated. I know I am, but I’m sure that it will all pan out in the end and definitely make it worthwhile. I’m sure Emma believes at least a little bit, sure she’s there for Henry but it seems to me like sometimes she does believe that MM is her mother. Time will tell!

[angiebelle]

Honestly, I just wish Emma would take the time to investigate what she is being told by Henry, August, and Jefferson….even if she doesn’t believe…instead of just brushing it off.

[charming]

@AngieBelle wrote:

Honestly, I just wish Emma would take the time to investigate what she is being told by Henry, August, and Jefferson….even if she doesn’t believe…instead of just brushing it off.

I do not know it is still a hard sell. It would take lets say…. Belle who she dioes not know that had escaped from the mental ward of the hospital to tell her. Emma goes with hard evidence and Henry and August are not good witnesses. she needs someone who she just met to confirm what Henry, August and Jefferson has said.

[nonnie]

NONNIE
What if someone brought you a copy of the Star War Trilogy and said to you, you are Princess Leia and need to help Luke Skywalker fight the Empire for the Republic. You just have to believe and in two days a starship will come and pick you up and go to the other side of the galaxy. You are our only hope………

boy with they be in trouble… I do not travel away from family… hate to travel and a star ship does not sound like something I would like

.

[once_dude]

lets take another look at this because some points i like were not mentionned:

1. the evil queen has a fondness for hearts (in the disneyy version of snow white the huntsman brings her a deer’s heart) what did Graham die of a heart attack. what did Emma find of Cathryn’s? her heart (seriously Emma you dont go back and say hmm Cathryn si alive i wonder where that heart came from)? She may not have seen the vault within the mosoleum but she knows for a fact that   there was something to hide there.

2. credile witnesses: Henry yes probably delusional. Graham was a figure of the law and so would be semi reputable. Jefferson’s story was given a slight bit of credence by Page as grace. August: very mysterious person but still trustworthy e.g. shovel.

3. If Emma had actually read the book instead of just claiming that she had read it and burning the pages which supposedly referred to her then she would have a lot of evidence the compass breadcrumbs, the heart connection, the mixture which Gold used to set Regina’s office on fire i don’t know, the scar on David’s chin. Emma had plenty of time to read the book and never did I would at least have read it because it would be something ot connect between me and my son.

So would I believe, maybe after episode 15 or so but seriously I would not take until Henry had to eat the poisoned apple turnover.

Magic always comes with a price, so I pay with visa.

[Author]

Posts