- This topic has 12,956 replies, 132 voices, and was last updated 8 years, 1 month ago by
.
-
Posts
-
Haha- I actually tried to edited Rumple in there- I think I deleted him out, when I edited a sentence before posting & forgot to add it back in- it’s after 3am here, so I’m not really with it lol- but yes Rumple is included in this- Robert, Lana, JMO, Ginny, Josh & Colin all are FANTASTIC emotional actors.
[adrotate group="5"]We got so many CS moments – SF just doesn’t exist at all in a romantic sense, in a family sense – absolutely. But other than that, I honestly see nothing else from either Emma or Neal to suggest any kind of lingering romantic feelings.
I agree. I mean, they love each other and always will, but you can see that the love is changing to a very different kind of love – that between friends. At least that’s my opinion.
That goodbye between Neal and Emma was 0% romantic IMO.
Because that moment coupled with whatever happened in the year they were apart resulted in a very different Killian showing up at Emma’s door.
Omg yes, I so agree. It’s so interesting, because Killian and Emma have only known each other for a couple of months tops, and now he feels confident enough to go around trying to bestow TLK???? I think her “good” gave him SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO much hope, it kept him focussed, focussed enough to not spiral at losing her or possibly never seeing her again.
I’m 99% sure Charming is the one who told him to try TLK, because he’s the only one who could have really. And Killian knew it was a “long shot” because I’m sure Charming would have warned him that it may not work, having experience with it himself.
Sooo, somehow Killian and Charming have become convinced that Emma and Killian are TL. HOW? I MUST KNOW RIGHT NOW. Possibly Tink, but there isn’t any fairy dust left??? Idk, soooo many questions.
Speculation alert: the back up plan to failed TLK must be to go to Neal’s apartment to see the dreamcatcher – this is how Emma will know for sure that Killian is telling the truth. Which must mean that Neal is in on this plan too!!!! Neal must ALSO think that CS are TL, or he’d be going himself.
And taking CS completely out of the equation, if Neal isn’t crossing worlds to find Emma, if he isn’t the one trying to give TLK…. well it just shows that he isn’t her TL. Because half the battle is the belief. And we have ALREADY been shown that Neal does not believe in his and Emma’s love “your belief in love wasn’t strong enough to overcome your fear of rejection”
And Killian, KILLIAN SEARCHED FOR EMMA FOR A YEAR, KNOWING THAT TLK WAS A LONG-SHOT, BECAUSE HE BELIEVED IN THEM
HE BELIEVED IN THEIR LOVE
UUUUUUUUUUUUUGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
Also, did it break anyone’s heart when Hook asked whether Regina could stop the curse or if they should start cleansing their souls or something like that because his was going to take a while.
See, it’s what CSers have been saying for a while, we KNOW he doesn’t always like himself, whereas everyone else thinks he’s just a cocky pirate who loves himself.
He actually loathes himself sometimes
And yes it broke my heart
My only beef is why did no one console poor Belle when she was hysterical over poor Rumple in the middle of the street?? I mean, not even a hug, a quick shoulder rub? Nothing?? Her boyfriend just vanished into thin air and is presumed to be dead having sacrificed himself to save the entire town and everyone just ignores her? Geesh!!
Maybe everyone was just in shock…?
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
To me, if Emma really wanted to have another shot with Neal or still loved him ‘romantically’ (because there is a BIG difference between loving someone & being ‘in love’ with someone IMO), the sentence structure would have been reversed- ie- something along the lines of ‘My secret is ‘I was hoping you were dead, because you hurt me so much, but I love you, I will always love you’ – to me that say’s ‘you hurt me, but not enough that I cant get over it, as my love for you is stronger than the hurt’- the 1st part might be true, but it’s the 2nd part that is actually the truth (I would have honestly been VERY worried for CS if they had worded the “I love you” as the but).
Me too!!! Agreed 100%. It’s all about the framing of the dialogue.
And kinda like that, I have an example: I was a tad anxious when the kiss sneak came out and there was no music. I knew when the episode actually aired that no music = not TL. BUT IT HAD OUR THEME SO ZERO WORRIES. 😉
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
I think it would. 1)When Henry was born Emma MUST have used magic somehow because the lights flickered. I’m pretty sure her emotions were all over the place. And Emma’s magic IS TL, so I’m pretty sure TLK would work, because if any magic would work in our world, the “most powerful magic of all” would. 2)The Dragon not only gave out magic potions, which I agree may not have been made in our world, but when Tamara confronted him about the potion he began to change form. So he could use magic in the land without magic. I don’t know, hopefully we’ll get some answers soooooooooooooon
maybe we can submit a question to Matt at the Paleyfest about it 1) yeah, that’s what I was meaning- Rumple kept saying magic wouldnt work outside of SB (he said it a number of times to different people), so how come Emma’s did & 2) yeah thats what I actually meant by the Dragon ‘using’ magic here … but this doesnt jive with what Rumple has been saying & he obviously believes it, since he only needed Emma because he couldnt magically track Bae out side of SB (like Charming did Snow & again with the Hatter)….. hmm I wonder if magic (of any kind) would work here now SB is gone.
Good Idea!
It would be nice to get some answers on that count- it’s very confusing having such contradictions hanging about like that lol.
I’m off to bed, before I make any less sense, than I’m making now. Sorry if my posts have been a little incoherent- So tired!
I’m off to bed, before I make any less sense, than I’m making now. Sorry if my posts have been a little incoherent- So tired!
Lol, sleep well!
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
Uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuugh
More pain and feelings in gif form
http://starchiee.tumblr.com/post/70182124343/1×10-3×11
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
Okay, the way he looks when he says he can make her remember and then grabs her and kisses her – I could stare at that forever. It’s like that mirror in Harry Potter that people have stared at for so long that they grow old and die in front of it.
That’s me. Growing old and dying as I watch that clip. At least I know what I’ll be doing during the hiatus.
Okay, the way he looks when he says he can make her remember and then grabs her and kisses her – I could stare at that forever. It’s like that mirror in Harry Potter that people have stared at for so long that they grow old and die in front of it. That’s me. Growing old and dying as I watch that clip. At least I know what I’ll be doing during the hiatus.
I KNOW RIGHT
It’s the new video I’m going to watch over and over… was totally obsessed with the kiss in NL but this
I mean
I knew we were going to get something good this week okay
BUT I DID NOT EXPECT
KILLIAN TO BELIEVE THAT HE AND EMMA COULD BE TRUE LOVE
AND TRY TO BESTOW TLK
I MEAN REALLY
HOLY CRAP
STILL NOT OVER IT
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
@rumplegoldfan – did you see the little side to side shuffle he does before he kisses her???
IT’S ADORABLE
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
The topic ‘The Captain Swan thread!’ is closed to new replies.