Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Zelena isn’t really wicked anymore. She has found love in her daughter Robyn. Regina isn’t evil anymore. She has found love within her family and Henry. Hook isn’t a bad pirate anymore. He has found love with Emma.
Just bc they found love doesnt mean they should not pay for their crimes and before im called bitter shiper, i say, Regina and Hook, i may even close my eyes and say they feel sorry for the things they do, or at least, the show paint them both as regreting some of the things they did, HOWEVER, no Zelena doesn`t feel sorry for the things she done and even gload them, in fact if there were social services in SB, they should totally take the baby from her and jailed her for life, not being rewarded as hero and as deserving of happy ending, when her victims happy ending were cut to a end, because of her.
Look at king george, in jail just bc he is not important to any of the Charming/mills family.Exactly. Why should George be in prison while there are four people who have done the same crimes as he did walking freely?
[adrotate group="5"]"All your questions are pointless"
Why should I feel bad for Hook, who murdered someone in cold blood (He didn’t even feel anything while he did that. Do you know what kind of people are like that? Psychpaths)? Hook has to deal with consequences, boo hoo.
If you don’t feel a little bad for Hook, then you will never forgive him for the man he used to be. And if you feel that way, then you must believe people cannot change or at the very least, should never even try to become a better person bc no one should forgive them. I’m not saying he shouldn’t have to deal with those consequences. I’m simply saying he accomplished a lot by getting Charming’s approval and convincing everyone that he is in fact a changed man. And it’s a shame that he came this far only to have to deal with things he’s done in the past again. I would feel the same way if Regina ended up being the one who killed Charming’s dad.
There is a limit. Hook never atoned for anything so his whole “redemption” is a joke in my opinion (as well as Regina’s and Zelena’s for all those who are ready to jump and call me a bitter shipper or whatever). I, personally, would find it hard to forgive someone who deliberately killed one of my family members even after they supposedly “changed”.
"All your questions are pointless"
Why should I feel bad for Hook, who murdered someone in cold blood (He didn’t even feel anything while he did that. Do you know what kind of people are like that? Psychpaths)? Hook has to deal with consequences, boo hoo.
"All your questions are pointless"
Husband and Wife for one episode and then separated forever. Real great show you’ve got there.
People are often reunited and then separated on this show. Neal brings back Rumple and dies forever. Regina is reunited with Daniel only to have to kill him in the same episode. Regina and Henry Sr. are reunited in the afterlife and she watches him depart. Cora comes back and is reunited with Regina (and to a lesser extent Rumple) and then dies. The show literally starts off with someone trying to separate a husband and wife forever.
I’m not saying I want Emma to die. I’m saying that I think it’s stronger storywise having her die (fulfilling her role as Savior since that does sometimes happen in their cycle) than to simply be off screen, never seen, but apparently still communicating with Henry. You don’t think it reads as incredibly cheap to have Emma “around” but never coming to save the day, see her family, or appear? I think that’s just straight up ridiculous. The writers would need a very sound reason why Emma wouldn’t be coming to fight the current Big Bad, whatever it is.
Even if JMo were to guest spot, having Emma ride in at the last second ater 11 episodes not appearing just to defeat the bad guy is…weird.
And furthermore who the heck says Jared is staying?
No one, certainly not me. I said Jared would leave and become the Adult!Henry. And seeing Adult!Henry without his mother(s) is depressing for me given that Henry relationship with both his mothers has been a bedrock of this show. Which means you need a very sound reason for Emma to not be around for her son. This leads me to…..
Again you’re not explaining how they will work the story of all these characters leaving.
Except I did. Snowing leave to the EF (a door, a portal, a bean, a heretofore unexplained plot device) to rule and rebuild. Regina likely stays (cause I think Lana would stay); Jared leaves but is aged up into the new actor so that the story now becomes Adult Henry and his adopted daughter, who I think might be the new Savior because the casting calls are gender reversed story parallels of Emma and Henry in S1 and because that’s how A and E roll, wheels within wheels. If we’re supposed to believe that this new Henry has become cynical then I can only imagine it’s because he’s lost Violet (his wife) and Emma (his mother) in death, the latter of which gets JMo off the show. Because they wont kill both Emma and Hook at the same time, Hook goes off on the JR, which also has the nice byproduct that he can return for guest spots.
Emma dying isn’t necessarily sad either. It can be bittersweet like how it was on Buffy 522.
"All your questions are pointless"
So if next season only consists of Wicked Sisters coming back, just end it now. Ratings won’t be able to get another season after the next one.
<p style=”text-align: center;”>
</p> But 7 seasons is more money for A&E than 6 seasons and the next one will probably be the final one regardless of who comes back, I bet A&E even know that.
It’s disgusting that they’re going to sell out just for another season and ruin their story.
I’m hoping now more than ever that they end it this season. And there’s plenty of episodes still to go and ratings could drop very quickly.
They sold out a long time ago. Frozen is the clearest evidence. The real story ended after 311. After that they focused on what will bring them most views and ratings, meaning doing fanservice – focusing on ships and doing Disney themed halloween party.
"All your questions are pointless"
So if next season only consists of Wicked Sisters coming back, just end it now. Ratings won’t be able to get another season after the next one.
<p style=”text-align: center;”>
</p>
But 7 seasons is more money for A&E than 6 seasons and the next one will probably be the final one regardless of who comes back, I bet A&E even know that.
"All your questions are pointless"
I don’t understand why does it matter that he was David’s father? If it was just random nobody, would it be ok? Would he feel bad about it?
"All your questions are pointless"
Does he even feel bad? Because to me it seems like the only thing he cares solely about himself and what he can loose from telling it.
Emma’s reaction should be something like “I know everything that you did because you did it to me” (Buffy to Angel 3.10) instead she’ll say “well you’re a hero now so who cares?!!”.
These are they’re thought about how to do redemption?
"All your questions are pointless"
I think you’re going to be seriously disappointed if you honestly think JMO is going to trash the show or CS even when the show is over. Because she actually loves the CS relationship and loves her character and the show. And has said this multiple times. The only people that believe it’s all “PR” are the ones that either ship a crack ship or just have this bad view of JMO and want to see it happen. It’s not going to happen.
No one actually knows what JMO’s about the show or the ships since she has never voiced an opinion about those.
In addition, this is a Swanfire thread so calling SF a “crackship” is unacceptable. This is one of the only few places across the web where we can talk about what should have been before A&E/abc changed it according to what they thought was popular based on a vocal aggressive part of the fandom.
"All your questions are pointless"
Regina is hated by one group from the fandom and it has to do more about shipping wars and less about the character herself.
Hook on the other hand is hated by all the people from the fandom who do not ship CS, even those who don’t ship Emma with anyone, mainly because of how other characters were treated by the writers in contrast to how he was treated.
"All your questions are pointless"
