Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Anyone else think we’re heading to a Rumple vs BF finale battle where instead of giving up his life he gives up his magic willingly and freely to defeat her?
[adrotate group="5"]Adult henry with Teenage Baby Snowflake going on adventures.
OUAT, CW’s Supernatural Style! ? If OUAT really did go the whole timeskip OUAT route…they’d have quite the cast. Adult Henry Mills Adult Gideon Gold Teenage Snowflake Teenage Alexandra Teenage Phillip/Aurora’s Son Teenage Robyn Mills
Would probably include a Henry S1 age CS child.
The library is not boarded up so I’m assuming it’s not S1. But they could just have forgotten or the library won’t be a part of the shot.
They’re shooting flashbacks, oh boy.
Good luck with explaining the new addition to the timeline RG. It’s like they literally don’t care if they destroy their timeline.
A magical day that happened while they were cursed and David was still married to Kathryn but she’s nowhere in site.
What a convoluted mess.
JMO has given no indication that she is leaving the show. She has stated that she has hope for a S7 and that she has no interest abandoning the character.
I would say if we’re losing anybody it’s Gosh especially from their storyline this season. It could have been a request by them so they could have more time with their family.
While I lean to Emma will get her happy ending. If Jmo leaves ( doubt she will) there is a possibility Emma could die with the peace and happiness to know her family is safe and protected. Import female and male lead characters die. Sleepy hollow is an example. And yet that show is trucking onward without her.
You couldn’t give a worse example especially because the ratings are tanking so bad this season without her and the show is definitely getting cancelled.
Neal whether you liked him or not was important to the show and was connected to many of the main characters. His death caused a lot of people not to get their happy endings. Rumple stated in Season 3 straight out that Bae was his happy ending, my point is, that anytime a character dies someone looses their happy ending. Robin’s death left Rolan without any parents (not very happy) Hades left Zelena without her budding relationship (not very happy) and Bae left Rumple in a complete and utter downward spiral which he is still struggling with, Henry without a father, and Emma without her love (none of that was happy)
He was only connected truly to one main character and that was Rumple. Rumple to me has always been the series big bad, so there’s no way he would get the happy ending he was intending. It was clearly to further his storyline that Neal died. If Bae was still around Rumple would have never done the things he did in S4 and onward.
You’ve listed a bunch of minor characters here. Emma is the main character, and has earned a happy ending more than anyone. There’s nothing happy about Emma dying just cause she’s the savior. 101 writing would tell you that the villain is wrong, and the hero does get a happy ending against all odds. She conquers fate, which many of our characters including Regina have said can be done. It’s not yep what Jafar said is right, Saviors never get to live happily ever after. LIVE in bold. That’s horrible writing, and the writers have no idea the backlash that would come from that mistake. So here’s hoping they definitely do the right thing and if she doesn’t sign for another season then have this season be the last. Simple as that or don’t kill her off and then have her pull a Nina Dobrev and come back the next season for the wrap up arc as a guest star in the end.
All this is speculation is over nothing because like I said JMO has given no indications that she’s leaving the show. Especially nothing compared to what Bobby has said.
Neal was not Emma’s love, especially not when he died. There was nothing between them during and after Neverland. The writers made that crystal clear. Just look at the difference between the CS goodbye and SF goodbye in Going Home. Night and day. One is depicted as clearly romantic while the other is way more platonic.
What kind of show actually shows you the villain is right, the savior dies. That would be absolutely horrible writing.
Not a Buffy fan, I take it?
Emma already went through her sacrificial “death” ie S4B finale and there’s a big difference between jumping into a hell gate that will destroythe Earth and literally losing a sword fight and being stabbed in the stomach. She took the place of her sister, whom was the fated one to die. Death was Buffy’s gift, and she took the place of her sister whom was made from her. That’s not the case with Emma, it’s just that oh she loses a swordfight bc of shaky shakies that have never appeared before. Big difference between the two scenarios.
In the same episode where Jafar says you never hear the words they lived happily ever after for the savior. That would be horrible writing if Jafar ends up being right and Emma does not live happily ever after because she’s the savior. That would be some of the worse writing I’ve ever seen and so many people would leave.
I would sincerely hope ABC has learned their lesson after the Castle debacle. But I also think Bar Farer has raised an excellent point: if S7 is the last (which it undoubtedly is) then depending on what A and E pitch to the network, Emma–while absolutely vital in our eyes–may not matter to ABC in the long run should JMo not wish to sign her contract.
Nothing that JMO has said indicated that she won’t sign a new contract. She’s retweeted the article talking about S7. Her and Colin were the only one’s in the cast. She talked about hope for S7 on her podcast. She said she had no intentions to abandon her character.
So why are we all doom and gloom? And since when has fate on this show been something that can’t be conquered? I fully expect Emma will defeat her fate.
May I also say that even if JMO does not agree to a full term contract for S7, she could always go the way of Nina Dobrev and come back near the end of the season to finish up her arc and the show.
She also is promoting the show still, going to a panel with the writers as well as Colin. That doesn’t sound like somebody that is going to leave IMO.
On a final note Emma is way more relevant and important than any other character on the show. Don’t compare her to the other characters that have died on the show. She is the most important character on the show, she’s the focal point of the show. She’s the reality of the show. Without Emma Swan, there’s no OUAT. She’s also connected to several people and without her all of our characters would not get happy endings. Hook, Snowing, Henry, etc will not get a happy ending. Sorry Neal fans but you cannot ever compare Emma to Neal. Also just saying but Henry was never close to Neal. Yeah he was his father but he barely spent any time with him. Sorry. Sure he misses him but it’s nowhere near the level he would feel if he lost Emma.
Also the season started with Jafar saying “you never hear these words of a savior, they lived happily ever after. What kind of show actually shows you the villain is right, the savior dies. That would be absolutely horrible writing.
