Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
[adrotate group="5"]
OMG poor Neal!
http://booksandfairytales.tumblr.com/post/91944519500/heatherc1212-wow
POOR NEAL! BAEBY!
*sob*
I can’t, I just cant!Hi everyone, I know I wasn’t missed here very much but I really missed you guys!
sigh
oh how I hate what they did to my favorite story!
it was once a story about true love, hope, happiness, and fairy tales. what is it now? a trashy romance novel.Yay! Puck is back home!
Wait, did @Text said :”hooray”? and did @Onyx post something with an optimistic aspect? OMG, OUR SAD TWINS ARE HAPPY AND TRYING TO SEE THINGS ON THE BRIGHT SIDE.
Lol no worries, it’s unlikely to happen again. Probably caught a fever of some kind. Making me say CRAZY things.
So long as they are crazy sad things
Hm… alright. How about this.
When Hook first shows is new outfit to Emma, she tells him how much he reminds her of this guy she used to date, she can’t remember his name though, but that doesn’t matter, because he looks so HOT in his normal outfit. Henry likes it too and tells Killian (he now exclusively goes by Killian) that he couldn’t wish for a more stylish new dad. Elsa then arrives at the scene and falls madly in love with Killian because well he’s just so HOT. Just the kind of guy she needs to warm her up. Then Elsa and Emma fight over him with magic and Henry gets caught in the crossfire. He dies. But Emma doesn’t mind because she’s won the fight and she will now make new babies with Killian.
Crazy sad enough for ya?
dandy.
Then Neal insisted that Emma would use her powers to separate him and his father, knowing it would mean finally his death, but he wanted her to do it, assuming his father was more important to stop Zelena and safe his family, Emma and Henry.
Neal AND Emma expected Gold to have a loophole. they “knew” that separating him from Gold would mean death, BUT they also *expected* that the source of all magical solutions would provide one here too.
Obviously.
oh,and of course he died for “naught” who was saved because of him? not even his father.
k am I allowed to be critical of the show on this thread?
The story of the father who let go of his son’s hand over the portal -after sacrificing so much for him- is the most compelling, heart wrenching story in all of TV. The story of a son who was raised by his coward father who one day became a monster and eventually abandoned him has the most potential for STORY instead of just face-time for actors on screen.
All of this tension all of this back and forth, can he trust him, will he run from him, will he betray him, will he ever know, can he ever apologize enough, will he ever come to the realization? Do they even know each other at all? Also, this whole saga of if (when) the relationship is amended, how it will effect either of their lives.
It became even MORE interesting and juicy when they added the peter-pan-being-the-grandfather revelation. Will Bae understand why his father never told him the truth no matter how much it cost their relationship? Will he ever know the magnitude of Pan’s betrayal of his father, the horrificness of it, the fact that in this abandonment story it was not the father holding onto the son’s hand but the little helpless traumatized son holding desperately to his father’s sleeve. This story didn’t have the father letting go of the son’s hand but the father violently pulling his hand away from his son’s pitiful grasp.
Will Bae ever know? Will he ever know where the name peter pan came from? Will he ever know that it was his baby blanket that kept his father safe in the land without magic? Will he ever know how his father reacted when he thought August was him? How Henry helped August trick Rumple? How Rumple gave Henry that protection from the burning room nightmare? How his father wrote Emma’s name over and over again so that he would remember when she comes to SB? Will Bae ever know that Emma arrested his father and put him in jail for beating someone up? Will he ever know how Regina managed to adopt his son? Will he ever know about his father’s disastrous relationship with Cora and how much he cares for Regina?
I mean OMG! can we make a list of all the potential STORY we could have had if Neal was still around to tell it?
Do you even know what the word “symbolize” means? The concept of symbolism? I never said he IS pure good, he symbolizes pure good. His father is not pure evil either, but he sure *symbolizes* evil.
Like the United States is the symbol of freedom, but are we really more free than other countries? (what with the patriot act, and income taxes etc.) still, we symbolize freedom just like Snow symbolizes purity and so does Bae. He symbolizes goodness and innocence. Well, symbolizED. He became evil in the end, but yeah…In the end…Neal died a hero.
A BOSS to the very end!
Bae was the symbol of GOOD in this show. just pure untainted goodness like that of child.. pure light, pure innocence. anything we ever saw him do was just innocent and good, like with the darlings and making that little deal with his father.
he was SUPPOSED to be the purer younger, more innocent mirror image of Snow. it was supposed to counter the Symbol Of Evil that Rumple became when he took the darkone’s powers. it was supposed to *mean* something to the overall theme of this show. (y’know, the symbol-of-all-that-is-evil protecting the-symbol-of-all-that-is-good)
but then in 315, Neal suddenly became a villain and died for nothing and for no one.
what is it that the story demanded here? was Neal/Fire too good? did he need that spot of darkness, like Snow had, to make him “three dimensional”?
were they planning to have him die and then brought back from the past by Rumple, so that Rumple would have a renewed goal? but why make him the villain? he definitely did NOT die a hero. far far from it.was it some sort of bold storytelling that we are yet to see, or was it just get rid of papa/bae to make room for more kissing time for rumbelle captainswan, snowing etc.?
