Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Not over neal, silly. If Henry would be murdered as he should be if we are in the midst of a tragic terrible story
MartyMcFly:
I know this pisses off some people but the direction this show is taking must include ALL the characters. If Neal dies EVERYONE hs to suffer too.
The center of the story is tragic, the rest has to follow suit. Gold should never have been freed. Charming should have died. Henry should have been murdured by enslaved Gold. Regina should have comitted suicide. Its the only way this story would have been believable.OR
They could have brought Neal back while timetraveling
WOAH! WOAH! WOAH!!!! Hold the phone!
Everyone has suffered, in their own way!
Charming and Snow have suffered because their daughter and grandson was heartbroken, Mr. Gold killed Zelena, Regina’s only sister and family, which will no doubt lead to her suffering in S4! Belle suffered because Mr. Gold suffered. And Regina also suffered because her son lost his father!
Neal’s death was a ripple effect, a rock thrown in a calm pond that caused many rifts that reached their destination at their own appointed time!
P. S. Why in the name of Once would Regina commit suicide over Neal???????????????? Neal had only been in SB for what….three weeks! And that one week in NL, along with the two days in SB before they were all back in EF.
[adrotate group="5"]If he is still the same character he was then no, he isn’t happy to have been ressurrected.
But the question is, IS he the same character?
Maybe I was watching a different show, but I remember the LAST time he thought his Baelfire was dead he was OK with Belle and all of SB and himself dying except for Henry. And then when he found Henry was in danger, he had something small to live for- save Henry at least.
And HOW they came to be together the HOW is that NEAL DIED. that’s how. Because of HOW they came to betogether is a VERY BIG DEAL.
And the fact tbat Gd would rather be dead than lose his precious child doesn’t make him suicidal. He was ALREADY dead
People keep forgetting that this is what killed his son.And people keep forgetting WHY he became a slave. He gavehis daggerto save Bae.
Doesn’t sound like a man HAPPY to be alive. If he would be tbe same character
Because of HOW they came to be together.
This is a very big deal.
But no one seems to care because as long as they get Married. As long as they KISS.GOLD DOES NOT WANT TO BE THERE. He wants his SON to be there. It’t a big deal.
Unless Gold is not Gold anymore.
Unless all the LIFE came out of tne show
It WAS more than a kissing relationship. When Belle was trying to help him open up to her. When Belle helped him tear down some of the walls he put up after being betrayed and abandoned again and again, and after abandoning his own son, the only person that kept him from being a full fledged monster.
It was after he finally told her about his child and what he did in order to find him that their relationship was finally at a better level
Now their relationship became all about “being together” not about feelings anymore. Now hes alive and free so they can kiss.
Never mind HOW he came to be alive. Never mind IF he wants to be alive. Never mind WHY he had to be freed (WHY he became a slave in the first place)
Agreed IF this was the story of B&B (animated version etc.) But it isn’t. It was a much better story of ouat. WAS. Here there IS a son. This son is a BIG part of what makes the Beast a Beast. So for Beauty to ignore that, makes their story a kissing tale of B&B and nothing more.
The only reason I don’t hate Gold yet is because in my headcanon I believe that he is working on getting Neal back. And probably die in the process. belle has already disappointed me. (its the writing of course, not Belle. But then again Belle isn’t really Belle anymore. If she was still the same Belle, she would think first about Neal. Before ANYTHING else. She would KNOW that he was the most important person in his father’s life.
Hopefully Henry doesn’t get killed next…
Oh but he should. It’s the direction this tragic story TOOK when Neal couldn’t be saved. ALL characters should suffer tragedy. It’s the only logical outcome.
This story has rotted from the center. It needs to collapse now
I know this pisses off some people but the direction this show is taking must include ALL the characters. If Neal dies EVERYONE hs to suffer too.
The center of the story is tragic, the rest has to follow suit. Gold should never have been freed. Charming should have died. Henry should have been murdured by enslaved Gold. Regina should have comitted suicide. Its the only way this story would have been believable.OR
They could have brought Neal back while timetraveling
Am I welcome in this thread? it’s not so much that I like SF, I dont ship. Its just that I really hate CS and the way it ruined the STORY
@csclover:
I am sorry that I now find your hook boring. I USED to love him, now I am nausiated by him and Emma.
I know, right?
Its all to do with the story.
Oh and yes I am furious at ABC for ruining a good story for the sake of kissing.
Anyone would be angry to see a beautiful work of art getting t pooped on.
