Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Cora, Pan, the Sultan — they’re all pretty bad in their own way. Each of them did pretty despicable things to their own children and all three actions ended with emotionally damaging their children, one way or another.
But I thing that sets them apart is regret. No regret, I’d say they’re horrible people altogether.
[adrotate group="5"]Last season, the title of the winter finale and the season finale, were perfect parallels with each other. Winter finale was called ‘Going Home’ and season finale was ‘There’s No Place Like Home.’
It wouldn’t shock me if Adam and Eddy do the same thing again this season. So, this season’s winter finale was called ‘Heroes and Villains.’ What if the finale is just called “Villains” ? We could see whether Emma decides who she wants to be and maybe Rumple revealing himself finally in Storybrooke. We also could get Regina’s storyline wrapped up there too.
The thing I think we missed with the Henry and Regina relationship is not really seeing the abuse that happened. We know Regina ignored Henry’s “it’s a curse thing” in season one but what I’m curious about here is the years before the pilot.
I think maybe both Cora and the Sultan. I agree, Baby Zelena definitely could have died if not for the incoming cyclone.
Cora also abuses Regina and abandoned her emotionally, thinking very little of her needs and basically what Cora wanted.
The Sultan was pretty bad too. He actually killed Jafar, held him under water and waited until he knew that he was dead.
If Lily sprung from the TL egg inside Mal, then she is full blooded sibling to Emma–they both have the DNA of Snowing, just that Lily wasn’t conceived in the “natural” way
That would mean Snowing’s decision not to help Mal screwed over both of their daughters. Way to go.
Aww.
I was thinking about this @slurpeez108 It would also mean that Lily and Emma are half-siblings are something.
What I don’t get is if Anastasia’s not dead, why is Will sniffing around Belle? Crack theory: Cruella and Ursula have have put Belle and Will under some sort of love spell. Evidence: Cruella lying that Belle has moved on from Rumple even though she clearly hasn’t then all of a sudden we see Belle has seemingly moved on.
Why this constant “sniffing around Belle” nonsense. You make her sound like she is just an object and has no free will. If Belle and Will are spending time together, it’s because they WANT TO. She wasn’t fighting off that kiss. She wasn’t kicking him out of the shop. She wasn’t rejecting his coffee. She looked very happy with him in that brief moment we saw. She isn’t the victim of unwanted attention. This is a mutual thing, however much we may dislike it for whatever reason.
Bless you @RumplesGirl!!!
I interpret that as Bobby saying that a happy ending shouldn’t just be handed to Rumple, he should earn it. He shouldn’t have a happy ending whilst he’s doing bad things. If he becomes a good person, then he should get one.
Oh, I totally agree Rumple’s happy ending shouldn’t just be handed to him. I think Robert even said one time that it shouldn’t be that way and happy endings should be earned.
But the thing about Rumple, he had a happy ending with Belle and he still screwed it up all, all on his own.
Isn’t Bobby also on record for saying he enjoys playing Rumple when he’s bad the most, and doesn’t think Rumple deserves his happy ending?
Yes!!! He did.
Question: So many of the Once Upon a Time characters have a history with your character – often, everything comes back to Rumple.
Carlyle: I know, it’s true. For me, it’s great, because it’s fantastic as an actor. A lot of the stuff that goes on, in the episodes, regardless of whether I’m there or not, has been driven by him at some point. All roads kind of lead to Rumple in the end.
Question: Do you see him getting a happy ending?
Carlyle: I don’t know. I really don’t know. To be honest, it’s… I think if you start to think of the characters like that then you’re going to start to lose the essence of what they are. Ultimately, they’re not meant for that world. The other characters — Snow White, Charming or whoever it is — these are the happy ending people. So whether these other ones get to that place or not is up to the creators. For me, I just don’t think it would be honest to do that. I think life just ain’t like that. You know, there’s good people and bad people.
http://www.ign.com/articles/2014/10/24/once-upon-a-time-can-rumpelstiltskin-ever-truly-change
