Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Will go back & read all the new posts after I’ve feed out, but having just finished watching the ep- I’m really not sure what to think- not about CS- I half expected what happened to happen (its the obvious play there- Emma mistrusts him…again, something happens to endanger him & boom, Emma trust in him is back better than ever *sigh* Wish just this once Killy actually pointed out he couldnt tell her without immediately putting Henry in danger- Emma is a BIG hypocrite there- It should have been HENRY’S choice on whether or not he went back to SB- Not Emma’s…again *sigh*)… anyway back to the point- I have a problem with the whole one heart/no heart stuff-
1) I mean come on! Really?! So we were supposed to believe the Graham “felt nothing” in S1 because Regina had taken his heart, but now because it’s convenient we are supposed to believe he did feel, just not deeply- WTH? Plot device much!
2) & one heart? ….. last I looked “breaking” someones heart in half = destroying it- why could they have crushed Charming’s heart & knocked some of the ash back in if it only requires “crushing” a heart- very very convenient that now you can literally twist a heart in 2 without A) turning it to dust *lol* or B) killing someone.
I’m also going to be honest when I say this- ‘dark curse’ now = ‘stupid/ not that big of a deal curse’- what happened to the whole “your heart will be filled with an emptiness that cant be filled” outcome- UGH!
On another note we were right, we guess (or at least I know I said this is how it could go down), that the good guys cast the curse, but WW interfered which is why there’s no memories 🙂
Grrrr, may I say Charming is back to being a judgmental prat again- Snowing, you have your memories from now & before- you know Rumple & Bae shared a body & that Bae “woke up” on occasions (this is where Emma is included here), yet cant imagine “who would send Hook a message at all?!” Prince, Snow & savior stupid is more like it- gees!
How many more times does Hook have to haul their backsides outta the flames & play the role of Captain Obvious before they actually pull finger & cut him some slack- it’s getting old :/ They ALL better give him one hell of an apology when this is done! Because I’m sick to death of them using Hook as the goody to shoes whipping boy >:(
UGH, just UGH!
& Emma’s “I cant trust you now” comment- I know she’s still broken from stupid Neal & Walsh’s actions, but for crying out loud! She has been LEADING him on! Not the other way around- she’s the heart breaker here & she cant trust him? Not sure I get that line- other than A&E trying to appease the SF fans & slow down the inferno that is CS LOL :p
[adrotate group="5"]UGH! have seen BOTH promos Before I’ve even seen today’s ep- TBH, looks more like TLK is gonna happen next week, since it looks like Hook is knocked out or cursed or something & Emma try’s to catch him as he falls while calling his name! I wanna know what happens THIS episode darn it- TIME HURRY UP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Just popping into say Happy once day guys!
Honestly dont think we’ll get a TLK this ep (at the risk of sounding a downer lol), because Emma’s love life isnt the focus of the story atm, but I’m happy for A&E to prove me wrong in my assertion there 😉
The only thing that will tick me off at this point is if Emma finds out about the curse & goes postal on Killy for not telling her about it- that would be VERY hypocritical of her, considering her out right lies to Henry atm.
Cant wait to see what A&E have in store for us today!!!!! *Rum & cookies to all- there’s probably bumpy seas ahead* 🙂
& Just because I think it’s worth noting …. again 😉
Ergo, anyone who insists they aren’t TL, is kind kidding themselves 😉
I actually really dont mind if something like this goes down, because it kind of makes sense in a lot of ways- esp from the writers/ A&E perspective!
So it looks like we’re getting a cs kiss in 3×19 but if it’s not a TLK that’s still ok so let me explain
I know a lot of people are assuming that, even though Hook’s cursed, that kissing Emma wouldn’t take away her powers because of the power of True Love’s Kiss. That’s a valid theory, but it’s not a fact. We don’t know how the writers are choosing to portray the nuances of TLK. Hook kissing Emma could very well take away her magic but that doesn’t mean that he and Emma aren’t True Love.
His curse was specifically put in place to potentially nullify a TLK (from more of a writer’s perspective than from what Zelena planned on achieving). I think it could be interesting for Emma to lose her magic and try to figure out how to be the Savior without it, and I think that the writers could have handled this in any number of ways but the fact that they chose Hook and his lips signifies that it was meant to contrast what we expect to happen with a TLK (or at least build up the suspense that it might).
And remember, you don’t need magic to perform a successful TLK. Look at Charming and Snow, or even Aurora and Philip. They don’t have magic but were able successfully wake up their loved ones. So I think, if we don’t get a TLK (and Emma just loses her magic) it could be a set up to have an actually successful TLK (which is gonna happen by the end of the season, it’s just a matter of when) that restores her powers and then she can defeat Zelena. So like, they’ll think all hope is lost but throughout everything Emma’s fully accepted her feelings for Hook and then they kiss and then BAM she has her powers back and there’s hope that they can be beat Zelena.
I honestly don’t know how the episode (or the rest of the season) is gonna go. But I don’t wanna hear people whining about something that may or may not happen. People get too invested in fan speculation and then take it as gospel, but then end up getting disappointed when it doesn’t pan out. Just watch the episode with an open mind.
If we get a TLK, great: everyone gets their memories back and Zelena maybe goes into hiding and then manages to travel back in time and that’s the struggle for the finale. If we don’t get a TLK, still good: Emma loses her powers and tries to figure out how to defeat Zelena without magic; when all hope seems to be lost, Hook and Emma eventually do share a TLK and then Emma is able to beat Zelena at the last minute.
http://gentlesleaze.tumblr.com/post/83816986594/so-it-looks-like-were-getting-a-cs-kiss-in-3×19
So my husband doesn’t seem to appreciate things the way all of you do . . .
I just showed him the picture of Roland and CS and said “OMG you have to see this picture, it’s the cutest thing EVER!”
*husband looks at picture *
HUSBAND: “Who is that?”
ME: “WHAT?? It’s Hobbit Baby with JMo and Colin behind the scenes!”
HUSBAND: “I have no idea what that even means.”
* I love you all *
Bahahahahaha, I get that with family members …. all the time 😉
Be prepared for some epic Captain Swan cuteness. This was just posted on Sean Maguire’s twitter.
NAWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW! Oh. My. Gosh! That is all sorts of Adorable!!!!!! *dies of adorable overload*
You guys want to read a funny Hook and Emma / Captain Charming meta all based around hair?
It’s awesome 🙂
*Giggles* Thanks for sharing, it is awesome! 🙂
Agreed @rumplegoldfan, Glad I’m not the only one 🙂
And then there is great rejoicing and merriment across the CS fandom!!!
Then cue Season finale & A&E deciding 2eps of CS rejoicing is more than enough, throwing our feelings under a bus, followed by a freight train, followed by a steam roller before sweeping them up & loading them onto the Kingda Ka roller coaster for a few rounds …. again lol :p
I also want Hook to tell Emma the truth. He needs to let her know what is going on.
I’ve kind of backed up a little in he “should” tell her as “she needs” to know.
I agree to a certain extent, but we have to remember WW told him IF he TOLD Emma, she was going to kill Henry- straight up. So he really is stuck between a rock & a hard place. I think at this point he is hoping Emma will be strong enough, quick enough, for her & Regina to take down WW Before it comes to him having to make a choice between saving the child he’s grown to care for (whom happens to be the son of 2 people he respects & the women he deeply loves) at the expense of taking an essential part of the women he loves away, or saving that part of the women he loves & knowingly risking/endangering her only child being murdered by a sicko on a power trip- either way in his mind it’s down to him who dies. As far as Everyone knows- Emma is NOT strong enough YET to take down WW, so in Hook’s mind, telling Emma wont just be putting Henry directly (& her other family & friends) in danger, but will also result in Emma doing something rash & getting hurt/killed anyway. It really is no win.
I just think in this instance it is as much- if not more Hook’s choice on what to do (tell her or not)- he’s the one that’s been cursed, he’s the one who has to decide who lives & dies- so it should be his choice on whether or not he takes the risk telling Emma & risking Henry’s life. I mean it swings both ways- he’s damned in many peoples eyes if he doesnt tell (he’s withholding info related to her & Henry) & he’s damned in the rest if he does (he’s willingly putting her family at risk & worse having her son be the instant target for WWs wrath/ murder promise).
For me it comes down to what would Emma really want here- to be in the know at the expense of Henry’s life, Or would she rather Hook play for time in the hopes she gets strong enough that the threat to Henry is reduced or eliminated all together & THEN tell her? I mean once Hook “tells” her, he cant take it back- Henry goes from having his life “threatened” to being an “actual target” for death- that distinction wont be lost on Killian at all & I think Emma would throw 8 types of fit if Killian put a death warrant out on her son by “telling her”, before he “really” needed to. I cant see Emma telling Snow her child was in danger if the shoe was on the other foot. TBH think she’d do Exactly what Killy is doing now- shut up about it & hope the situation changes in their favor, so she can ‘safely’ tell.
