Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
surayya
Participantlol- the blink & you miss it moment đ
[adrotate group="5"]surayya
ParticipantCan you talk about the flashbacks weâre going to see to Emmaâs childhood this season?
Itâs not going to change who Emma is now. A lot of it is whatâs already been built into her character in terms of her being shuffled between foster homes and things like that. There is some stuff thatâs going to be revealed that actually impacts everyone in the sense that thereâs just some information that comes out about her past that changes the overall puzzle that weâre all considering in this story. I know thatâs incredibly vague. [Laughs]
Emma and Hook have decided to take it slow. Whatâs ahead for them?
We do see them go on a first date. As always, thereâs a lot going on. There are concerns about Regina (Lana Parrilla) being heartbroken over Marian (Christie Laing) coming back and she wants to try to help anyway she can, so thatâs distracting. Thereâs a snow monster in town, thatâs distracting. We eventually encounter Elsa, so thatâs distracting. Then we discover that thereâs an evil Snow Queen (Elizabeth Mitchell), so thatâs distracting. Thereâs just stuff going on thatâs in the way of them just having a happy-go-lucky situation. But theyâre trying. Theyâre trying to figure out how to get to know each other amidst all these crises, and how to make time to go on a date. Itâs a very unique take on the beginning of dating.http://insidetv.ew.com/2014/10/03/once-upon-time-jennifer-morris-spoilers/

I saw a really neat theory recently that maybe the Snow queen knew Emma as a child or fostered Emma at some point, which is why she’s after Emma & Emma’s reaction to seeing her again is what sets off Emma’s nerves, causing her magic to become uncontrollable. I mean I was wondering what else Emma could possibly have been through in the foster system, that’s still holding her back (other than random acts of magic) & that would explain some of it.. I thought it was really interesting anyway.surayya
ParticipantHaha, I do just have to make one comment about the script tease and âhatersââŚapparently they are interpreting it as Hook attempting to buy Emma. That is awesome, just because you really have to be out of your mind to get that from the script tease! Those hatersâŚ.they used to upset me, now they just make my day with their insanity! Probably not the effect theyâre looking for, howeverâŚ.
Yeah, I just love that since what heâs saying is actually in support of Emmaâs individual rights as a woman! Heâs mocking the old-fashioned idea of a woman being âownedâ by her father until sheâs transferred to a husband.
I had a chuckle at that as well- damned if he points out women have a right to choose who they want to be in a relationship with, damned if he holds his tongue & says nothing LOL Some of the things they come up with really are laughable đ
surayya
ParticipantI pretty much agree with Epona’s replys
1. The âWhen I jab you with my sword, youâll feel itâ line. I can see how that particular line could be interpreted as a little on the sexually threatening side. Iâm not saying it is as each individual line doesnât throw up any âred flagsâ, however, when it is preceded by the ânormally I prefer to do more enjoyable activities with a woman on her backâ line, the context it is said in becomes more sexualised. The issue people have with the âWhen I jab you with my sword, youâll feel itâ line isnât with the âjabâ which the metawriter seems to think, itâs with the âswordâ. People are interpreting âswordâ as a euphemism for penis. Also the situation that the line was said in wasnât ideal. It wasnât a relaxed atmosphere, it was combative, Emma and Hook were battling to âwinâ, etc. Also I think part of it is to do with the perception of both male and female characters within the media. For example, you are more likely to see women represented as victims of men in the media rather than vice versa. So in a situation where Emma is on her back which is considered a submissive position whilst Killian is âon topâ in what is considered the âdominantâ position and making the innuendo, I can see why people may see him as being sexually threatening towards Emma. On a side note, the entire Alien film franchise is built on the premise of male rape and sexual threat. It is what makes the films more scary than your average slasher film.
The point she was making is that line/scene cant be considered promotion of rape culture, if Hook isnt actually taking away Emma’s ability to make choices- just because a euphemism makes someone uncomfortable, it doesnt mean it’s takes away someones ability to make a choice… what was said cant be twisted into “forcing himself” on Emma, as the word choices are ânormally I prefer to do more enjoyable activities with a woman on her backâ preferring to do something is not the same as “demanding or insisting”… âWhen I jab you with my sword, youâll feel itâ When isnt the same as “Now I’m going to whether you like it or not”. It was designed to shock Emma, but didnt. At no point does he say “I am going to jab you with my ‘sword’ & you’ll feel it”- That could easily be considered promoting rape culture, but that is simply not what was said.
2. Where did the writer get the idea that Milah worked in a tavern? I donât recall that being said in-show. Milah spent a lot of her time at the tavern but thatâs probably because that was the one place where she wasnât made to feel like a pariah. Taverns didnât care who you were so long as you continued to drink and spend your money.
I’m with both Epona & yourself on that score- I have no clue if her assumption is correct, I always thought Milah was a housewife :/
3. I strongly disagree that âRumple punishes Hook further by not killing him so Hook decides to remove Belle from him by shooting her in the shoulderâ. What Hook did to Belle was just plain wrong. He didnât just shoot her in the shoulder, he took away her memories, he took away her IDENTITY. I had no problem with Hook stabbing Rumple in 215 (I didnât like it but I had no problem with it). Rumple wasnât âpunishingâ Hook by not killing him, Rumple wouldâve happily killed him, Rumple was trying to show Belle that he did have good in him and that she wasnât wrong. Belle was encouraging Rumple to do the right thing, yeah she may have been more Rumple focussed, but Hook had tried to kill her previously. I noticed in the meta the writer left out the scenes of Hook in Belleâs cell and Hook at the library. If anything, Hook went after Belle unprovoked. Belle hadnât done anything to Hook so Hook wasnât actually being âhonourableâ in his treatment of Belle.
Epona already answered the circumstances here (being when Rumple murdered Milah on the JR etc.)
I feel that meta kind of tried to whitewash Hookâs past misdeeds a little. I get that the aim of the meta was to prove that Hook doesnât promote rape-culture and it does achieve that, however it does feel like there is a little whitewashing in there specifically in Hookâs treatment of Belle. We all know I wasnât Hookâs biggest fan during season 2 but still, he his past misdeeds should be acknowledged alongside Reginaâs and Rumpleâs.
Epona’s response pretty much covers mine here as well, I will add that the meta was directly & solely in response to his actions with regards to promoting rape culture- not if his deeds where douche bag moves or heroic, if they where justifiable or not etc.- I think pretty much all of us agree that Hook has done somethings *hitting Belle is the biggest IMO* that are down right wrong & contemptible- but then, to be fair to Hook, we have to remember Regina & Rumple have both bodily thrown people into solid objects & caused them to lose consciousness, which is no different to punching them IMO, as the end result is the same- physical injury that causes them to lose consciousness at the hands of someone else- ie. Rumple tossed Red bodily into a tree & knocked her out cold, for me just because Rumple used magic, doesnt mean he didnt intentionally cause physical injury to a women (Red), that resulted in her losing consciousness- The same applies to Regina. Magic IMO doesnt give Rumple or Regina a “it doesnt count” pass on the violence they commit- but then thats just my opinion đ
One thing of interest in that meta though was the definition of rape culture etc etc which includes ââ˘Dehumanization of femininity â calling people âsissyâ, âpussyâ, ânot a real manâ, etc.â I bring this up in relation to the Milah and Rumple relationship especially when Milah is mouthing off at Rumple in the tavern when he says she had responsibilities and she replied âyou mean like BEING A MAN and fighting in the ogre wars?â Milah is implying that Rumple wasnât a real man because he didnât fight in the ogre war, then in 401 during Rumpleâs speech to Nealâs grave he said that when he had comforted Bae, for the first time in his life he âfelt like a manâ. By the meta writerâs definition of rape culture, wasnât Milah, by implying that Rumple wasnât a man for not fighting in the ogre war, participating in the âDehumanization of femininityâ?
I think in that particular case, you need to take context into consideration- it is absolutely clear Milah didnt say it as a euphemism for his sexual prowess, she flat out said what she meant & this is confirmed later when they talk in the hovel, so it wouldnt be considered promotion of rape culture.
Please remember this is just my opinion, but I think his speech at the grave has to be taken with a grain of salt- Rumple chose to go to war- he had to have “felt like a man” when he chose to do so, he also had to have “felt like a man” when he asked Milah to marry him & she accepted. Milah lost respect for him AFTER he willingly maimed himself to get out of fighting in the war & brought shame down on them all, then flat out refused to leave the village & start fresh elsewhere, so if he felt less of a man AFTER maiming himself because of Milah’s loss of respect, then maybe he should have moved & started fresh (& no I dont condone Milah being a cow to him, but I do understand why she was, the same as I dont approve of Rumple deserting the war he signed up for, even if I understand why he did so)- again just my opinion.surayya
ParticipantIt sounds like itâll be a great scene â and say a lot about all involved. Davidâs going to try to be Dad because he never got to beâŚand Killianâs going to toss a little sass back with an unsaid âEmmaâs a big girl and we both know sheâll make her own decisionsâ thrown in for good measure. I love the idea of David trying to be Daddy to Emma and get rebuffed by everyone in earshot â because hi David, have you met Emma?! (Snow not so much â unless they keep the Snow from the Sneak Peek around â if you havenât seen it go check out the threadâŚ.it is AWESOME).
Agreed & yes I want more badass Snow around! I’m seriously hoping that continues đ
surayya
ParticipantHaha, I do just have to make one comment about the script tease and âhatersââŚapparently they are interpreting it as Hook attempting to buy Emma. That is awesome, just because you really have to be out of your mind to get that from the script tease! Those hatersâŚ.they used to upset me, now they just make my day with their insanity! Probably not the effect theyâre looking for, howeverâŚ.
LOL! I know right! They are so hard case, you cant do anything but laugh at them- they are a seriously funny bunch these days.
BEST REACTION GIF EVER!!!!!! *does the CaptainCharming happy dance** YES, this is exactly what Iâve been waiting for. Charming had better remember that fireside chat he had with Prince Charles. Hehe, yeah it pretty much sums my facials when I read that script tease đ
Yes! He had better remember that conversation- I do hope Killy says something along the lines of “I’m pretty sure I made that clear in the EF” or something like that to him đ Gentle reminder & a nice call back if they did đ
surayya
Participant
surayya
ParticipantSome new CS vids- incorporating E01 stuff in them to get us through the next 2days đ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vJHPNs72r_8
JMo on some CS stuff in an interview yesterday-
TVLINE | And as a result, Hook and Emma might be taking it slow?
Yeah, I think so. Thereâs a lot to figure out. And weâre trying to figure out if we can be together in midst of snow monsters and creatures chasing us and an evil Snow Queen in townâŚ. Trying to figure out complicated dating issues in the midst of crazy chaos makes for some really funny things, some very serious things, some very heartbreaking moments, some very exciting moments. It really definitely turns dating into a true adventure.
TVLINE | In the premiere, Emma reassured him, âBe patient.â But itâs been a while since the show has had anything close to a love scene. Might Emma and Hook eventually end that dry spell?
I hope so. Thatâs about all I can say.
TVLINE | What role, if any, does Emma play in Hookâs makeover? Is it something she initiates? Something she helps out with?
Oh, he does that all on his own. He is very fashionable, that Captain Hook.
TVLINE | Does Emma have a reaction?
Of course!I just got so much more excited about that ep when I read Killian simply goes off & buys new clothes for himself….. I can.not.wait to see Emma’s reaction to his new outfit! đ
http://tvline.com/2014/10/02/once-upon-a-time-preview-jennifer-morrison-emma-elsa-regina-hook/
surayya
ParticipantAndâŚ.
Iâm dead. Happy dead. But dead.
https://twitter.com/AdamHorowitzLA/status/518144569712447488/photo/1

*bounces off chair & dies a happy, happy Oncer….. I am a ghost*
YEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!! I knew it & I love it & I cant wait!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Thank you sooooo much for sharing that @Jenna_B đ đ đ đ đ đ đ đ đsurayya
ParticipantGlad youâre enjoying your trip, @Obisgirl! Youâre definitely in for a great premiere when you return! Welcome back, KJ! The rest of you lurking around, come on out!!
Theyâre stuck and she canât seem to break herself out of this fear. Emmaâs life is in danger so David and Hook bromance out and come to the rescue and David talks Elsa down off the ledge with a lot of things that Anna taught him a long time ago.
AndâŚthatâs probably all I need to make Sundayâs episode awesome in my book. My 2nd favorite ship!
*Squeeeeee* This episode just sounds better & better!!!!! Is it Once day yet?! đ
-
AuthorPosts




