Emma + Baelfire = Swanfire

[RumplesGirl]

Adam and Eddy’s attempts at justifying the decision are crap. I dunno what universe they live in where they thought this was a good and natural development for the story. It was anything but.

Henry abandoned by his father through death.

Because this show has always been about continuing that cycle. OH WAIT

[RumplesGirl]

:'(

I have no more words. I don’t know where we go from here.

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[lecygne]

Adam and Eddy’s attempts at justifying the decision are crap. I dunno what universe they live in where they thought this was a good and natural development for the story. It was anything but.

They need to explain (1) why it was necessary, (2) why it was necessary now, (3) why it was necessary in this way.

They also need to explain why they didn’t write it.

[lecygne]

:’(

I have no more words. I don’t know where we go from here.

I guess I’ll take my cue from A&E and pretend like I never watched this show…

[annwyn]

annwyn wrote:

I didn’t like Graham death and I wasn’t into him, I just felt it was unfair… such an aweful life when you look at it. And now Neal… Is redemtion and happy ends only left to villains and trickers?! And I love Rumple, and seriously started to grow on Regina. Hook I won’t comment. But Graham, now Neal… Is that the message of this show, that nice guys will be screwed and, suck it that’s how life works? I don’t remember who says “I’m sick to my stomach”. I am too.

Graham… yes. Sad. But he was incidental. A minor FTL character with no real ties to Emma, the curse, or whatever. NF… major (OUAT) FTL character, reason for the curse, Henry’s father, EMMA’S CANON TRUE LOVE, etc etc etc. This blows that death out of the water. And then when I think about all the @(#$&%^^ fake deaths on this show.

Actually Graham”s death was important plot wise (or rather I feel like it), it made Emma aware and awaken. But in my eyes, and seriously I wasn’t a Graham fan, I liked him fair enough but no more, his death didn’t crush me, but I thought : “man the guy had it rough…”. And now Neal. I seriously feel that appart Snow and David the good guys just meet the gutter -_-*

 

Anyway, Swan (=)), I have to edit : I’m really half listening to be honnest because I’m just so… I read but don’t listen, I need time to get through it too. Seriously, I’ll never understand what they did to Emma and Neal.

Goodn night guys. Hey let’s keep this thread alive, it’s really an awesome thread and full of awesome people. Huge hugs and sorry if I’ve been inappropiate, a bit rude, I’m totally devasted and seriously not understanding. Ty guys for being there. Currently, to me, this show sux. More “mature wise” I seriously do not understand what they have done. They created Bae for God’s sake.

Ok, time to shut up. Love you guys. Love you my swan =)

[Ranisha Pitts]

Its easy for them because their favorite character is safe its like all well we can move on now because yay we get our ships and snowing baby.

I’m sorry this was A &E way to tie up the LT because they couldn’t figure away around it. This their way of what they thought about taking out what they thought was unpopular character. This wasn’t a bold decision, bold decision would be letting Rumple stay dead. If this was there plan they could have more with Neal, they could let him be the one to show up at Emma’s door, bond with Emma, bond with his son, and them him make an ultimate sacrifice to help Emma save the town. Yet we spend most of the time wondering what happen to Neal only to have him show up and die in 3 episodes of second arch. Neal got the Tamara shaft the only exception was that Neal was loved.

"I will be kind but I will speak my mind."

[koffeegirl]

I’m finishing up work but wanted to post this  real quick–all the articles keep pointing out that rumple gave up hia dagger to save bae, but here’s the kicker—Neal has no memory of it bc it was the cursed year so he doesn’t he have that to remember! It s been bothering me that everyone writing articles seems to miss that fact

[RumplesGirl]

AND NOW PEOPLE ARE TELLING ME HOW I SHOULD OR SHOULD NOT BE COPING WITH THE DEATH OF MY FATHER?

THAT YOU JUST HAVE TO HAVE HOPE TO LIVE ON.

I AM SO MUCH RAGE RIGHT NOW

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[theoniongirl]

Wow. I knew I was holding on when I shouldn’t be, but … I guess TV Line put paid to that.

Guys, this might sound silly, but anyone want to have a … wake of sorts … of our own? All log in at a certain point some evening this week and raise a toast?

To Neal and how it should have been.

OK. How does 10 p.m. Eastern Wednesday (April 2) strike everyone? I’m picking this at relatively random to get the ball rolling. (Just need it to be after my kids go to bed.)

---
“Though lovers be lost love shall not;
And death shall have no dominion.”
-- Dylan Thomas

[lunatiger]

theoniongirl wrote:

Wow. I knew I was holding on when I shouldn’t be, but … I guess TV Line put paid to that. Guys, this might sound silly, but anyone want to have a … wake of sorts … of our own? All log in at a certain point some evening this week and raise a toast? To Neal and how it should have been.

OK. How does 10 p.m. Eastern Wednesday (April 2) strike everyone? I’m picking this at relatively random to get the ball rolling. (Just need it to be after my kids go to bed.)

I’m cool with that, or any day for that matter. I’ll give my toast to Neal before bowing out from OUAT.

[Author]

Posts