Home › Forums › Once Upon a Time › General discussion and theories › The Captain Swan thread!
- This topic has 12,956 replies, 132 voices, and was last updated 8 years, 10 months ago by
TheWatcher.
-
AuthorPosts
-
May 31, 2014 at 1:12 pm #271903
Jenna_B
ParticipantHaha I was going to post that 1st gifset too, @callmeLola! There hasn’t been one Husbands of Storybrooke post that hasn’t made me crack up. (And ok, still trying to figure out how to post them – did you have to do it pic by pic or were you able to post the entire thing at once?)
Ugh, The Notebook. I can’t handle those movies/books, that are just about a romance. I agree, @Obisgirl, I need a nice mix in my movies!
[adrotate group="5"]May 31, 2014 at 3:50 pm #271917sweetgrass
ParticipantI’ve been thinking of a couple of things I would like to see next season, but I don’t expect to see them.
1. I would like for Killian to have kept drawings done by Milah and Bae while they were on his ship. I would like to see him share some of Bae’s drawings with Henry and Rumple (kinda). For Rumple, either Henry would show Rumple some of drawings with Rumple or Rumple hears them watches Hook and Henry go through some of the drawings at Granny’s. Belle might even ask if Rumple can join them. I would like Rumple being snarky about all the pirate, pirate ship and even Hook drawings, but then get very emotional over a drawing of the old Stiltskin hovel with him spinning at the hearth when he was just a poor spinner with no power, but Bae’s papa, showing that Bae never forgot or stopped loving his papa. I could see Carlyle (sp?) play the hell out of that scene. I would then like it if Hook and Rumple talk about Bae and it deepens their truce. See for me, I think Hook would know who Bae as a person was, far more than Rumple. Rumple was too busy trying to secure Bae’s love and safety that he couldn’t see what Bae needed or really wanted. Hook could and Rumple would want to know what his son was like.
You know I think I will write a fan fic on this.
2. I like Hook and Regina being frienemies. They are good together. The snark flies well between them and they have similarities. So the scene I would want is for Hook to ask Regina what she felt the morning after she thought she had killed Snow. Did she feel empty like he did when he thought he had killed Rumple? Hook may want to know to see how dangerous Regina is, but it is also a chance for Regina to show some regret and make her not so psycho.
Keeper of Hook and Emma's smoldering first kiss, a certain Pirate's sauciness, the Evil Queen's snarkiness, Grumpy's gruffness and a drop of true love to make it all go down smooth.
May 31, 2014 at 4:14 pm #271919callmeLola
Participant. I would like for Killian to have kept drawings done by Milah and Bae while they were on his ship. I would like to see him share some of Bae’s drawings with Henry and Rumple (kinda). For Rumple, either Henry would show Rumple some of drawings with Rumple or Rumple hears them watches Hook and Henry go through some of the drawings at Granny’s. Belle might even ask if Rumple can join them. I would like Rumple being snarky about all the pirate, pirate ship and even Hook drawings, but then get very emotional over a drawing of the old Stiltskin hovel with him spinning at the hearth when he was just a poor spinner with no power, but Bae’s papa, showing that Bae never forgot or stopped loving his papa. I could see Carlyle (sp?) play the hell out of that scene. I would then like it if Hook and Rumple talk about Bae and it deepens their truce. See for me, I think Hook would know who Bae as a person was, far more than Rumple. Rumple was too busy trying to secure Bae’s love and safety that he couldn’t see what Bae needed or really wanted. Hook could and Rumple would want to know what his son was like.
Wow, we have a similar headcanon! For someone who claimed repeatedly not to be sentimental, Hook sure kept a lot of stuff. I’ll bet he still has Milah’s drawings and would be more than happy to share them with Henry.
@Jenna_B I copy and paste the gifs one by one. I don’t know how to do it any other way so if someone has any suggestions on an easier method, please help!I took my kids to see Maleficent last night. I thought was okay. The kids LOVED it though. After watching Once and how they turned fairytales around, the ending was easy to figure out. It’s True Blood’s final season so maybe they can have Kristen Bauer back on Ouat as Maleficent. I love her! If Regina kept Mal alive in whatever state she chose, then A and E left the door open for her to come back. Probably the Black Fairy storyline.
May 31, 2014 at 6:10 pm #271940PriceofMagic
ParticipantFound this on tumblr and it made me laugh
When you smell food

When you realize it’s food you don’t like

All magic comes with a price!
Keeper of FelixMay 31, 2014 at 6:53 pm #271946PriceofMagic
ParticipantSee for me, I think Hook would know who Bae as a person was, far more than Rumple.
I disagree with this.
Between the age of Birth and 14, Rumple knew Bae the best, especially after Milah left. Bae was everything to Rumple so you can bet that Rumple knew the ins and outs of what Bae liked, disliked, what size clothes he wore, any allergies he had, probably even his favourite colour, favourite meal, favourite game, etc. However, once Rumple became the dark one, this is probably where Rumple and Bae began to drift apart. Rumple began to be too over-protective of Bae to the point where Bae felt smothered by Rumple. As Bae began to pull away, Rumple tried to pull him closer until their relationship began breaking down.
When Bae fell through the portal, he would’ve changed as a person since he had to survive on the street (My crack headcanon is that Bae was Once’s version of Oliver Twist or at least knew him or get involved with Fagin’s gang. Alas we’ll probably never know what Bae did in those 6 months between falling through the prtal and being taken in by the Darlings) Any way a person can change in 6 months, so the Bae Rumple knew was not the Bae that met Wendy.
When Bae went to Neverland after being with the Darlings for however long, he would’ve changed again since he was on the streets. He would’ve gone from having to take care of yourself Bae to feeling loved and part of a family Bae. He probably had a new favourite meal, would’ve grown so would be a different clothes size, would have had new things to like and dislike, would play different games from when he was younger, etc.
It’s unclear how long Bae was with Hook on the ship (ASOTM made it look like Bae and Hook were together not long at all until he was retrieved by the Lost Boys, however Hook makes out it was longer) so Hook would’ve gotten to know Bae whilst he was on the ship. However, once Bae was off the ship, he would’ve changed again as he had to cope living on Neverland. Hook must’ve kept tabs on Bae since he knew where Bae’s cave was, but I don’t think they were close per se because:
1. Bae thought Hook sold him out to Pan.
2. Hook wouldn’t have risked showing any sort of emotional attachment to Bae or else Pan would’ve probably used it against him and it would’ve put Bae at risk of harm.Obviously once Bae left Neverland, he would’ve changed yet again as he grew into Neal.
So whilst I think it’s unfair to say Hook knew Bae better than Rumple (especially as Rumple knew Bae years compared to Hook’s weeks/months), it would probably be fairer to say each man knew Bae best at a certain point in his life (Rumple between Birth and 14, Hook between 14/15 to when Bae left his ship). Both men can talk about the time when they knew Bae best which the other would not know about and they could also talk about any new things they’ve learned about Bae from Emma about the time SwanFire were together. However there would also be parts of Bae that will forever remain a mystery to Rumple and Hook as nobody would know what he got up to in the 11 years between leaving Emma and being found again in Manhattan. People change in 11 years so the Bae they both knew was no longer the person Neal was.
All magic comes with a price!
Keeper of FelixMay 31, 2014 at 8:17 pm #271956surayya
ParticipantI just saw this – Cant believe I totally missed it last season!
Funny how cast was already spelling out Hook changing back in (mid) S2, yet the haters still insist on saying he hasnt changed LOL
May 31, 2014 at 10:42 pm #271964callmeLola
ParticipantFound this on tumblr and it made me laugh
When you smell food

When you realize it’s food you don’t like

HILARIOUS!!! Thanks for posting.
@surayya, don’t know how many times I’ve seen that video……… I could listen to that accent all day long 🙂June 1, 2014 at 12:18 am #271980Epona_610
Participant@surayya Where did that come from? I hadn’t seen it either but that’s a fun video–thanks for posting it! I particularly enjoyed the sword-fight question; I’d love to see that on the show (we haven’t seen that, have we? I need to re-watch this season, haha), although preferably in practice or something, not actually trying to kill each other…
June 1, 2014 at 10:24 am #272041PriceofMagic
Participant@Surayya, I’ve never seen that video before even though it has the channel 5 logo at the very beginning. Thanks for posting.
Colin is adorable and lovely and it shows how capable and talented he is as an actor where he can be so lovely and the character he plays (especially season 2 Hook) isn’t.
All magic comes with a price!
Keeper of FelixJune 1, 2014 at 6:26 pm #272087surayya
ParticipantI have no idea where it comes from @Epona- I just happened to see it in the side bar of the youtube vid I was watching & thought I hadnt seen it before lol
Agreed POM 🙂
-
AuthorPosts
The topic ‘The Captain Swan thread!’ is closed to new replies.