The Captain Swan thread!

[surayya]

Came across this on tumblr though it was interesting “Belle and Hook are not characters anyone would usually see as similar, but there were definite parallels to be made between them in this episode. From having their darkest points of self-loathing preyed on to feeling immense guilt for choosing a selfish option instead of saving a life (Hook followed that same guilty path in Season Three’s “The Jolly Roger”), it was interesting to see these two characters’ inner conflicts paralleled so deliberately.” Nerdy Girl Notes

Yes it was very interesting them making that connection, wasnt it …. I LOVE Nerdy girl 🙂

 

[ellemo78]

Killian Jones wrote:

Came across this on tumblr though it was interesting “Belle and Hook are not characters anyone would usually see as similar, but there were definite parallels to be made between them in this episode. From having their darkest points of self-loathing preyed on to feeling immense guilt for choosing a selfish option instead of saving a life (Hook followed that same guilty path in Season Three’s “The Jolly Roger”), it was interesting to see these two characters’ inner conflicts paralleled so deliberately.” Nerdy Girl Notes

Yes it was very interesting them making that connection, wasnt it …. I LOVE Nerdy girl

I thought so too. Who would ever think to parallel those two!

Oh yes I like Nerdy Girl as well! I’ve started to read all her reviews now. It’s nice to have positive spin on things for a change.

Speaking of positive, this: http://winger-hawk.tumblr.com/post/101838595748/i-love-your-theories-metas-and-i-hope-they-pan-out-i -is IMHO an awesome description of Season 3 and it also goes into Regina’s light magic (which was the headcanon I had of sorts) It’s not CS, but I thought you guys might appreciate it. (Also had no clue where else to post it!)

If one is to engage with the primordial forces of darkness, one must expect a little social awkwardness

[ellemo78]

<p style=”display: inline !important;”>Crazy theory… What if she is rehabilitated and goes after people who she thinks isn’t treating animals right</p>

Very interesting 😀

They kind of did that in 102 Dalmatians. CDV after serving her time was reformed and made to work for an animal shelter, but if she reverted to her old puppy-napping ways her entire fortune went to all the animal shelters in the borough. Aaaaand you can probably guess what happened in the end 😉

If one is to engage with the primordial forces of darkness, one must expect a little social awkwardness

[surayya]

surayya wrote:

Killian Jones wrote:

Came across this on tumblr though it was interesting “Belle and Hook are not characters anyone would usually see as similar, but there were definite parallels to be made between them in this episode. From having their darkest points of self-loathing preyed on to feeling immense guilt for choosing a selfish option instead of saving a life (Hook followed that same guilty path in Season Three’s “The Jolly Roger”), it was interesting to see these two characters’ inner conflicts paralleled so deliberately.” Nerdy Girl Notes

Yes it was very interesting them making that connection, wasnt it …. I LOVE Nerdy girl

I thought so too. Who would ever think to parallel those two! Oh yes I like Nerdy Girl as well! I’ve started to read all her reviews now. It’s nice to have positive spin on things for a change. Speaking of positive, this: http://winger-hawk.tumblr.com/post/101838595748/i-love-your-theories-metas-and-i-hope-they-pan-out-i -is IMHO an awesome description of Season 3 and it also goes into Regina’s light magic (which was the headcanon I had of sorts) It’s not CS, but I thought you guys might appreciate it. (Also had no clue where else to post it!)

That was actually very interesting, I hadnt thought about Robin’s goodness being the reason TLK would work for Regina & Regina being able to use light magic…. I think she hit the nail on the head as to what the writers where going for there.

I must admit her bit here made me chuckle:

So if you’re looking for the source of that Regal Believer TLK and the white magic that defeated Zelena, look no further than the man in green with the bow and the arrow.

My mind immediately went “Who?… Arrow/Oliver Queen” LMAO 😛 😉

[surayya]

Arianne Grace wrote:

<p style=”display: inline !important;”>Crazy theory… What if she is rehabilitated and goes after people who she thinks isn’t treating animals right</p>

Very interesting

They kind of did that in 102 Dalmatians. CDV after serving her time was reformed and made to work for an animal shelter, but if she reverted to her old puppy-napping ways her entire fortune went to all the animal shelters in the borough. Aaaaand you can probably guess what happened in the end

I totally need to watch those movies if they are going to do that story lol

[surayya]

Is anyone listening the podcast still? How has it been?

[ellemo78]

That was actually very interesting, I hadnt thought about Robin’s goodness being the reason TLK would work for Regina & Regina being able to use light magic…. I think she hit the nail on the head as to what the writers where going for there.

She hits the nail on the head quite a lot. I’m not 100% with her on her Killian gaining magic theory, but most of the analysis is rather good. (Although having said that, we see two people go to take his heart, but they haven’t actually taken it out of his chest. I’ve always wondered if there was something in that, echoing Emma’s heart not being able to be removed)

I never thought of it actually being Robin’s goodness that helped her with light magic (but I think that makes a lot of sense) I assumed it was because she didn’t have her dark heart, blackened by all those horrible things she had done, weighing her down that her light magic could come to the fore. And the lightness was amplified when Robin held her heart. But I like Winger-Hawk’s theory better.

I must admit her bit here made me chuckle:

So if you’re looking for the source of that Regal Believer TLK and the white magic that defeated Zelena, look no further than the man in green with the bow and the arrow.

My mind immediately went “Who?… Arrow/Oliver Queen” LMAO

Hee I’m definitely old school, the man in green with the bow will ALWAYS be Robin Hood for me 😉

If one is to engage with the primordial forces of darkness, one must expect a little social awkwardness

[surayya]

surayya wrote:

That was actually very interesting, I hadnt thought about Robin’s goodness being the reason TLK would work for Regina & Regina being able to use light magic…. I think she hit the nail on the head as to what the writers where going for there.

She hits the nail on the head quite a lot. I’m not 100% with her on her Killian gaining magic theory, but most of the analysis is rather good. (Although having said that, we see two people go to take his heart, but they haven’t actually taken it out of his chest. I’ve always wondered if there was something in that, echoing Emma’s heart not being able to be removed) I never thought of it actually being Robin’s goodness that helped her with light magic (but I think that makes a lot of sense) I assumed it was because she didn’t have her dark heart, blackened by all those horrible things she had done, weighing her down that her light magic could come to the fore. And the lightness was amplified when Robin held her heart. But I like Winger-Hawk’s theory better.

surayya wrote:

I must admit her bit here made me chuckle:

So if you’re looking for the source of that Regal Believer TLK and the white magic that defeated Zelena, look no further than the man in green with the bow and the arrow.

My mind immediately went “Who?… Arrow/Oliver Queen” LMAO

Hee I’m definitely old school, the man in green with the bow will ALWAYS be Robin Hood for me

Yeah, I’m not sold on the Killian with magic bit either lol

Hehe, I was never a big Robin Hood fan.. dont know why… but Avengers Hawk Eye & CWs Arrow, they are my kind of men in tights with bow & arrows 😉 When did Robin get dreamed up? I know Arrow has been around since the 1940’s I think it was, so how much older is Robin – weird question I know, but google is not my friend on this ph .

[Killian Jones]

Is anyone listening the podcast still? How has it been?

 

I have! I need to tune in to more live shows but I mean things have been good positive and stuff. 🙂

[surayya]

surayya wrote:

Is anyone listening the podcast still? How has it been?

I have! I need to tune in to more live shows but I mean things have been good positive and stuff.

Ok, thanks for that- might give them another shot again 🙂

[Author]

Posts