The Captain Swan thread!

[Captain Eala]

So yeah looks next epsidoe is gonna be a doozy.

Er sorry can’t read anything of what you’ve just posted above, it’s all code-y 🙂 have you got a source link?

I have this btw:

“As for Captain Swan, there’s more good stuff coming up in episode two. Hook doesn’t seem to be trying to hide the fact that he fancies her and Emma doesn’t seem annoyed by his presence or the attention he gives her in the slightest, which is pretty awesome. They have plenty of moments that will be gifs in a matter of a seconds.”

CANNOT WAIT.

[obisgirl]

hookian, the best thing to do is to copy and paste stuff to notepad or click on the text tab for simple text and then copy and paste. then switch back to visual for spoiler tags.

I’m excited for upcoming episodes.

[obisgirl]

So, this is my current Google Chrome theme. CS is my life.

[Captain Eala]

So, this is my current Google Chrome theme. CS is my life.

Love it. Just downloaded it 🙂

Just found this:

Talking about Hook, the incorrigible innuendo loving pirate couldn’t help himself telling Emma in front of the entire group, including her parents…that ‘Actually I quite fancy you from time to time – when you’re not yelling at me.’ Emma gave him a glance as in saying  ’Really now it’s not the time!’ but we do believe Hook meant every word. The scene where he’s holding his breath, sighing with relief as Emma started to breathe again after almost drowning, tells us all we need to know about his feelings for the saviour.

http://www.entertainmentoutlook.com/2013/10/04/upon-time-lost-girl-look-forward/

So it looks like CSers aren’t the only ones who interpreted things that way. Some people from other ships are saying that she was really annoyed with him, but it’s clear that she wasn’t, because she would have shut him down by now if she was. He’s been making his interest in her clear from day 1 😉

Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss

[PriceofMagic]

My preference for CaptainSwan or SwanFire varies but here’s how I think the CaptainSwanFire triangle may play out.

1. Emma and Hook get close in Neverland. Obviously it won’t go into fullblown romance because Emma is focussed on finding Henry, but it will be enough for Emma to admit that she does have feelings for Hook.

2. Neal shows up in Neverland. Everyone is shocked to see him alive, Emma is the most shocked. She is immediately sent into a whirlpool of feelings. Emma pushes Hook away, because she needs to get her head straight, because that’s what Emma does. Hook sadly stands aside because he cares for BOTH Emma and Neal and he wants them to be happy even if it’s with each other. Emma and Neal seemingly reunite.

3. Hook is hurting but he wants Emma and Neal to be happy so he does his best to leave them be. At this point a bottle of rum becomes Hook’s new best friend. However, Emma isn’t happy. She’s still in a spin over Hook and Neal’s return. Neal is happy that he and Emma have reunited and that Henry is safe and that they’re a proper family, that they’ve “found Tallahassee”. Emma plays along, not wanting to disappoint Neal or Henry, but she still feels guilty about Hook. (I think Rumple or Regina would be the first to notice that everything’s not okay with Emma, since they are the only two that have been in an unhappy marriage but had to pretend that everything was happy and okay for the sake of a child).

4. Hook and Emma try to avoid each other, try and pretend that they had nothing more than a mere flirtation, try and move on, etc. Hook wants to get Emma out of his system by having “one last look” since he believes him and Emma are no longer an option since she’s happy with Neal. Emma catches Hook having his “one last look” and they are forced to confront what happened in Neverland. (I think Neverland will be something none of the JR6 really want to discuss). Emma admits that she still has feelings for Hook but wishes she didn’t and that they would just go away. Hook asks if she is happy with Neal. Emma hesitates but says yes, because that is what she wants to believe, because that’s how she thinks she should feel. Emma goes home to Neal whilst Hook returns to his bottle of rum.

5. Neal has noticed something is up with Emma. He asks if she is happy with him. Emma says yes. Neal asks her if that is the case, why doesn’t it feel like it. Emma tries to lie and give lame excuses but eventually breaks down and tells Neal about what happened in Neverland with Hook. Neal is JUSTIFIABLY upset- his last words with Emma were “I love you” to each other, he went through a lot to get back to Emma, etc. Neal confides in Rumple about the situation with Emma, and Rumple gives Neal some good honest advice (Basically, staying together just for the sake of a child will only lead to misery for everyone aka Rumple’s and Milah’s marriage). Neal returns to Emma and they discuss their relationship, all there was, is and ever could be. Neal lets Emma go because he wants her to be happy, even if it’s with Hook. Cue tears all around. (The SF break up would be dignified for both parties, there would be no Emma just ditched Neal for Hook)

6. Emma talks to Charming. Emma is upset, and fears that she has “messed everything up”. Charming comforts Emma and asks her what SHE wants. Emma says she doesn’t know except that she wants Henry to be happy. Charming tells her that Henry will be happy if she’s happy, Henry wouldn’t want her to be miserable for his sake.

7. Emma goes to see Hook. She tells him that her and Neal are no longer together. Hook says he’s sorry to which Emma replies “no you’re not” (In a banter kind of way, Hook and Emma have always had banter). Hook admits he’d be lying if he wasn’t hopeful that the CS break up meant there was a chance for him and Emma. Emma admits that her feelings for Hook still remain and that she’d like to explore them further. HOWEVER, she would like some time and space to come to terms with her break up from Neal, which Hook GLADLY gives her.

8. Hook and Emma may be together but Neal is still a big part of Henry’s life. Neal still gets on with Emma and Hook but has also found someone new in his life.

I actually wouldn’t put it past the writers to end the series with Emma faced with a choice between Hook and Neal. We never get to see who she chooses but then everybody would be happy. CSers can believe she chose Hook, whilst SFers can believe she chose Neal.

All magic comes with a price!

Keeper of Felix

[obisgirl]

PoM, can CSF discussion please stay in the CSF thread?

[PriceofMagic]

I have posted it in the CSF thread but I thought I’d post it here as well since it leans more towards CS than SF.

All magic comes with a price!

Keeper of Felix

[obisgirl]

I think it would be better to keep CSF discussion in the appropriate thread, which is the CSF one.

[PriceofMagic]

So Neal isn’t allowed to be mentioned at all in the CS thread?

All magic comes with a price!

Keeper of Felix

[sweetgrass]

POM –  for what it’s worth, I thought three post should be here.  I worry it will upset the sf’ers in the other thread.  This is why I hope this triangle gets resolved this season.

Keeper of Hook and Emma's smoldering first kiss, a certain Pirate's sauciness, the Evil Queen's snarkiness, Grumpy's gruffness and a drop of true love to make it all go down smooth.

[Author]

Posts