- This topic has 12,956 replies, 132 voices, and was last updated 8 years, 2 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
OMG! captaineala thanks for posting that lovely essay by sincerelygsh. By far, one of the best posts comparing the difference between the Captain Swan and Swan Fire goodbye.
After watching 3×11, I was convinced that Emma’s love for Neal was not romantic in nature – not true love – because of the goodbyes. And yes, the expressions that Jennifer and Colin display in that scene are amazing to watch! Remember in Season 1 when Kathryn tells Regina that she is letting David go? Kathryn shows Regina the pictures of David and Mary Margaret and says something like “Do you see the way they look at each other? They are in love.” This so applies to Hook and Emma and of course Snow and Charming.
I just want to add, I think Emma didn’t approach Hook first because she was still hurt from seeing Tinkerbell and Hook together. That incident hurt her deeply and the jealousy completely took her by surprise. Remember Rumple telling Emma in 3×01 that she was just a bails bond person – still looking for evidence? The Tink/Hook incident made her doubt Hook’s feelings for her. On the other hand, Hook approached Emma after she spoke to Neal. He was doing exactly what he said – backing off. He obviously witnessed the platonic goodbye between Emma and Neal and felt free to tell her – well, we all know what he said!
[adrotate group="5"]You’re welcome!!! 🙂
And yes, the expressions that Jennifer and Colin display in that scene are amazing to watch! Remember in Season 1 when Kathryn tells Regina that she is letting David go? Kathryn shows Regina the pictures of David and Mary Margaret and says something like “Do you see the way they look at each other? They are in love.” This so applies to Hook and Emma and of course Snow and Charming.
<:) Our babies are in love
even if Emma is unaware as of yetI just want to add, I think Emma didn’t approach Hook first because she was still hurt from seeing Tinkerbell and Hook together.
A lot of CSers have been saying that it was kind of like Friends when Rachel left but didn’t say goodbye to Ross because it was too hard. I think that could apply here.
Anyway, it has always been Killian who has been emotionally vulnerable – that’s the way the dynamic has been so far. So it was consistent with the character build that he would be the one to approach her. Though i think for 3B the vulnerability will be more balanced 🙂
That incident hurt her deeply and the jealousy completely took her by surprise. Remember Rumple telling Emma in 3×01 that she was just a bails bond person – still looking for evidence? The Tink/Hook incident made her doubt Hook’s feelings for her.
I definitely think you’re right, but i think it applied more to 3×10 than 3×11. I think the hurt she felt in 3×10 spurred her into realising that she cared about him a lot. So when he basically told her again that he loved her.. she realised that she WANTED that love.
He obviously witnessed the platonic goodbye between Emma and Neal and felt free to tell her – well, we all know what he said!
Personally i don’t think this is the case. It’s a parallel to 3×01 for me – Emma almost died/Killian almost lost her, and that spurred him into telling her that he fancied her. So then in 3×11 when he realises he’s actually losing her… he was like “well i’m going to tell her how i feel.” And he did 🙂
Perfect ship is perfect!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
https://twitter.com/IamTaraMarie/status/422778571883421697
@IamTaraMarie he doesn't know
— Adam Horowitz (@AdamHorowitzLA) January 13, 2014
I have to give you all credit you could be in chat gloating that they mention who is going to get married Emma/Hook or ……. I think if the the shoe was on the other foot the other shippers would be in chat exploding with joy and chatting away.
Kudos to all you for taking the high road and avoiding confrontation!!!
Kudos to all you for taking the high road and avoiding confrontation!!!
Thanks HE!!! And thanks for the tweets as well 🙂 I think it’s mostly because we’re pretty confident here that CS are TL so.. we don’t feel the need to go tooting our horns about it. Well I don’t anyway lol.
I don’t think it’s a Captain Swan wedding, in fact I’m pretty sure it’s Rumbelle. If it’s going to be a big season finale then it has to be a big wedding… so I would definitely say it’s Rumbelle. What I personally want to see, is Killian in a tux 😉 If he’s even invited that is lol!!!!!!
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
I doubt if it is Rumbles wedding too, Belle isn’t that important as Emma and Regina are Emma is a Princess and could have a big wedding nobody really likes Rumple after what he did to everyone remember when he wanted help finding Belle in SB. No, it has to be either Emma or Regina and I think it is too soon for Regina too but I could be wrong. This season is suppose to be about Regina.
PS Another character I don’t like is Belle—sorry, I might be just the only one.
It HIGHLY doubt it will be Emma, she’s only just after accepting that she cares for Killian at the moment. She won’t be ready for a wedding by the end of the season. You could be right about Regina – who knows what sort of development has happened between her and Robin in the past year? But at the moment, I’m thinking it’s likely to be Rumbelle. Belle isn’t that important no, but Rumple is.. I liked Belle in season 1 and some of season 2… but this season I’m pretty meh about her. She hasn’t had any real character development to me. Her reactions to Rumple’s villainy are all over the place – Neal has been mentioned TWICE as Rumple’s Happy Ending, not Belle. Neal has been more important to Rumple throughout the series so far, which is very consistent with Rumple’s character arc.
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
I liked the idea of it being Ariel and Eric, only because it would probably only be the backdrop for way more interesting things happening!
Wow – the chat is getting heated, LOL. I will stay far away and enjoy my happy CS thread! What I love about this show is that once a couple is established as TL, there’s no breaking them up. None of the drama that others shows have in terms of people switching between love interests. So once we get our confirmation that’s it for good!! Can’t wait!!!!!
The funny thing was I didn’t even mention CS yet they were like “oh you’re a Hooker which normally means CS”. Way to judge someone. People are unbelievable.
I will stay far away and enjoy my happy CS thread!
Yes this is a good idea. We all understand each other here 🙂 sometimes we have different opinions but we don’t get into arguments, which is what makes for good discussion!!! 🙂
I liked the idea of it being Ariel and Eric, only because it would probably only be the backdrop for way more interesting things happening!
I’m not sure, it just doesn’t seem important enough to me for a finale wedding? Idk maybe the coming weeks will give us some hints!! 🙂
So once we get our confirmation that’s it for good!! Can’t wait!!!!!
ME NEITHER
The funny thing was I didn’t even mention CS yet they were like “oh you’re a Hooker which normally means CS”. Way to judge someone. People are unbelievable.
Yeah… that’ts the reason I stay in this thread lol. We apparently can’t enter chat without bringing shipper stuff into it!
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
The topic ‘The Captain Swan thread!’ is closed to new replies.