The Captain Swan thread!

[kfchimera]

@obisgirl wrote:

Maybe Emma thinks Neal is in league with Tamara and Greg.

I could see Emma thinking maybe Neal is supporting Tamara's anti-magic agenda, but the part that throws me is “and Greg”. She may not be the sharpest sheriff on the block but if she knew Tamara and Greg knew each other, she is going to channel Rumpel in Manhattan. “You two know each other.. You two KNOW each other…..” And more importantly for this thread, how is Emma going to react to Hook working with Tamara and Greg? Or does he turn them down flat, or betray them at the right moment ? Do you think Hook would hurt Regina/put her at risk, and would Emma care at this point if he did? What if he saves Regina?

[surayya]

@KFChimera wrote:

@obisgirl wrote:

Maybe Emma thinks Neal is in league with Tamara and Greg.

I could see Emma thinking maybe Neal is supporting Tamara's anti-magic agenda, but the part that throws me is “and Greg”. She may not be the sharpest sheriff on the block but if she knew Tamara and Greg knew each other, she is going to channel Rumpel in Manhattan. “You two know each other.. You two KNOW each other…..” And more importantly for this thread, how is Emma going to react to Hook working with Tamara and Greg? Or does he turn them down flat, or betray them at the right moment ? Do you think Hook would hurt Regina/put her at risk, and would Emma care at this point if he did? What if he saves Regina?

You have just articulated almost all my thoughts about this subject lol
I’ve matched font colours in response, so I don’t have to break up the quote & have black boxes everywhere 😉

Hard to say without context- it'll depend on whether or not she knows he's back in town & if she & he know at that point, what GOAT have in store for Henry or not I guess.
GOAT & Hook, are the one part of the episode I waver back & forth on- due to the same questions you have stated- I cant help but remember his sullen expression & demeanor in the cave when the girls got locked in Rumples cell- he wouldn't really look at them- esp when Cora pulled out the heart- which would indicate he wasn't entirely comfortable with what was playing out at that moment, but it was his only way to get to Rumple & get back at Emma, so he was having to take it.
I just don't know at this point if he will simply 'buy' into what Tamara/GOAT is selling without proof (I hope not considering Cora & Regina have just used him) & that could be where Regina enters (Owen could take her by surprise & knock her out with the taser), as a demo to prove they can kill/take magic (I'm hoping at that point they try to take it to far, he backs out, taking Regina & snitches, if he hasn't already turned them down flat). Concerning Regina, She would do Hook more good alive than dead- she blames Rumple for her mother's death as much as Snow & Hook has already stated he doesn't kill unless he has too, so I'm wondering at this point, if when Hook raises his hook, it's to free her of bindings or something…. it's not like he killed Emma for leaving him up the bean stalk, so I cant see him killing Regina for following her mothers orders either….but maybe that was just because he 'genuinely likes' for Emma…..hmmm, darn it now I'm 2nd guessing that part as well 😆
I think how much she'd worry about him killing her, would come entirely down to context, she doesn't (that we know of) think less of Snow for taking out an evil, bent on her families deaths/destruction women- who was Henry's step granny 😉 Personally I don't think Emma would be overly worried herself, either way (but CaptainSawn would be a much further reach, if it was cold blooded when she is defenseless) but Henry loves Regina & still wants her around, so that is what she will fight for- If Henry let her go, it'd be all over red rover I think

[kfchimera]

@Surayya wrote:

]

You have just articulated almost all my thoughts about this subject lol
I’ve matched font colours in response, so I don’t have to break up the quote & have black boxes everywhere 😉

That’s a good idea! I thought mostly along the same lines as what you answered.

“If I had a world of my own, everything would be nonsense. Nothing would be what it is, because everything would be what it isn't. And contrary wise, what is, it wouldn't be. And what it wouldn't be, it would. You see?” -- Lewis Carroll, Alice's Adventures in Wonderland & Through the Looking-Glass

[surayya]

Not sure if this has already been shared or not, but here is what JMo said when asked if there’s anything going on:

[HappyEndings]

I hope not, Hook slept with her Grandmother for petes sakes.

[Killian Jones]

@HappyEndings wrote:

I hope not, Hook slept with her Grandmother for petes sakes.

What? Emma’s grandmother(s) are Regina, Queen Eva, and Ruth and as far as what we’ve seen Hook slept with none of them, as far as Hook and Milah come on that was 100s of years ago is that really a reason against CaptainSwan

[AllThatGlitters]

@HappyEndings wrote:

I hope not, Hook slept with her Grandmother for petes sakes.

Well, that’s your opinion.

Milah is not related to Emma at all. Emma is not blood related to Rumpel’s family. Therefore, I don’t think it is a big issue.

Besides, by the end of the series they’ll all be related! 😉 😀

Find me on tumblr: http://allthatglittersonce.tumblr.com

[HappyEndings]

Yes, it is Hook slept with her what I should have said Henry’s grandmother, Bae’s mother that is really sick to me to have Emma tied up with this guy. He beats up women like Belle, steals, left her in prision, has an affair with her future father-in-law wife, then runs away with her and leaves Bae without a mother. Boy this would be the guy you want to bring home to your parents don’t you think?

[craxyfox]

noone’s perfect 😉

Hook actually never put Emma in jail, if I recall correctly, Neal was the one that did that 😆

[HappyEndings]

@craxyfox wrote:

noone’s perfect 😉

Hook actually never put Emma in jail, if I recall correctly, Neal was the one that did that 😆

Hey, left her in Rumbles cell in FL with Snow, Aurora and Mulan.

[Author]

Posts