Home › Forums › Once Upon a Time › General discussion and theories › The Captain Swan thread!
- This topic has 12,956 replies, 132 voices, and was last updated 8 years, 10 months ago by
TheWatcher.
-
AuthorPosts
-
January 20, 2014 at 7:15 am #238708
PriceofMagic
ParticipantBut how can Neal still have an apartment if he hasn’t been in NYC for a year?
To be honest i doubt this will be addressed! *sigh*
Neal might have a standing order set up where his rent automatically gets paid, especially if he has enough savings. So long as the rent is getting paid, the landlord won’t come knocking.
[adrotate group="5"]All magic comes with a price!
Keeper of FelixJanuary 20, 2014 at 7:15 am #238709CaptainEala
ParticipantBelle is a very forgiving person. I said this three or four pages back and I’ll say it again, if Belle’s not dwelling on what happened, we shouldn’t dwell on it.
I agree 🙂 that’s exactly where i always come from. If it bothers the characters – it should bother me.
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
January 20, 2014 at 7:15 am #238710CaptainEala
ParticipantNeal might have a standing order set up where his rent automatically gets paid, especially if he has enough savings. So long as the rent is getting paid, the landlord won’t come knocking.
I wonder where he’s getting the money from though? Yeah i think it’s just gunna be skimmed over.
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
January 20, 2014 at 7:26 am #238711obisgirl
ParticipantHey obisgirl
I was wondering if you’d come around after I saw your tumblr post hope you don’t mind that I put it over here?It’s fine, as long as I’m credited. I saw that after typing out my long post Lol.
January 20, 2014 at 7:43 am #238712Killian Jones
ParticipantAs for Hook turning up at Emma’s door, I don’t dislike Hook, I just dislike what he did to Belle and Rumple, I’m a RumBeller first and foremost so Hook is quite a divisive character for me. I can ship Tallahassee Hook with Emma but not The Outsider Hook.
well I’d say the Hook Killian is being now is way more Tallahassee than Outsider. through the whole Neverland arc he’s tried to do good. Charming toasted him a hero! Aside from that look at his attitude toward Rumple’s sacrifice Outsider Hook would have been over elated perhaps even helped Pan. This Hook looked like he genuinely felt bad at seeing Rumple “die” like that. The most “wrong” thing Hook’s done this season is make a pass at Tink while he was feeling down about having stepped aside for Bae to have a fair chance. Of course the situation changed so it was impossible for him to let Emma just go from his life without telling her something of how he feels for her So we get the goodbye we saw.
I think if Killian felt that Emma would bring more danger to herself or her family by coming back he would just leave her in her happy ending with Henry. For him to come back aside from his love for her they must really need Emma’s help. Neal not being there is anybody’s guess I would have thought both would go after her. Even if Emma and Neal are more platonic now I don’t think he’d leave Henry if he had a chance to get to him. He doesn’t want to leave his son without a father. Something had to have gone into it being Hook to come back, he may love her but she also has her parents why didn’t one of them come back? Hook must have been in a position where he was their best chance to bring back Emma to help them all.
January 20, 2014 at 8:23 am #238713zoeandnimo
ParticipantOk, finally caught up today. Feeling much better about things! LOL. I won’t doubt our ship again! Thank you for the screaming spoilers @captaineala – they are my favorite! 🙂
January 20, 2014 at 8:52 am #238720CaptainEala
ParticipantOk, finally caught up today. Feeling much better about things! LOL. I won’t doubt our ship again! Thank you for the screaming spoilers @captaineala – they are my favorite!
Hahahaha!!!! 🙂 Glad you’re feeling better 😉
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
January 20, 2014 at 10:43 am #238744CaptainEala
ParticipantThis Hook looked like he genuinely felt bad at seeing Rumple “die” like that.
I think the finale was VERY interesting for Hook and Rumple – even if it wasn’t made obvious. Killian has obviously changed his mind in terms of thinking Rumple an irredeemable monster.
And i think Rumple empathised with Killian in a way as well – he almost cut off his left hand with the same sword he used to cut off Killian’s. These things aren’t done by accident.
I think if Killian felt that Emma would bring more danger to herself or her family by coming back he would just leave her in her happy ending with Henry. For him to come back aside from his love for her they must really need Emma’s help.
I’m kind of conflicted on this. Emma said her memories “wouldn’t be real” and that it didn’t sound like much of a Happy Ending. So i’m kind of conflicted as to what Killian did in the year – did he push to find a way back to Emma? Did he feel like she was happy and didn’t want to ruin it? So many questions.
Hook must have been in a position where he was their best chance to bring back Emma to help them all.
Honestly i ZERO percent care about this. The fact is, the writers chose to send Killian, not Neal. They chose to injure him (which i think unlikely personally) or they chose to make him passive, or they chose for the decision to be taken out of his hands. IT LITERALLY DOESN’T MATTER. Killian is the one who is there, who is bringing back her memories, who is bringing her HOME (BELIEVE A LOST GIRL CAN FIND HER WAY HOME, BELIEVE A PIRATE CAN BE A HERO), who is attempting True Love’s Kiss.
THAT IS FREAKING HUGE
Like Adam and Eddie said, what matters is the HOW AND WHEN, not the WHY, Killian went after her.
(in a bit of an antsy mood lol sorry if i’m too ranty)
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
January 20, 2014 at 10:46 am #238745Aurora
ParticipantI requested this one specifically. Bright, slow motion, big gifs, close up. Hehe. Enjoy the SMOOCHIES


[x]
Phew the temperature of the room just raised by a few degrees ha ha!
January 20, 2014 at 10:47 am #238746Aurora
ParticipantIT LITERALLY DOESN’T MATTER. Killian is the one who is there, who is bringing back her memories, who is bringing her HOME (BELIEVE A LOST GIRL CAN FIND HER WAY HOME, BELIEVE A PIRATE CAN BE A HERO), who is attempting True Love’s Kiss. THAT IS FREAKING HUGE Like Adam and Eddie said, what matters is the HOW AND WHEN, not the WHY, Killian went after her.
Yeah I agree. TLK is pretty huge, you can’t just throw that around 🙂
-
AuthorPosts
The topic ‘The Captain Swan thread!’ is closed to new replies.



[