The Captain Swan thread!

[craxyfox]

where’s my Hook?? I need more Hook D:
I’m not buying into this Emma & Neal thing though 🙂

[sarah_tn]

@craxyfox wrote:

where’s my Hook?? I need more Hook D:
I’m not buying into this Emma & Neal thing though 🙂

I get the feeling the Hook/Emma encounter will not be a friendly one next episode. If I’m right, I will be so disappointed, and disillusioned. I kow it’s somebody else’s show, but do I really want to be a consumer of that product? The jury is out for diliberation. 🙁

[craxyfox]

I have that feeling too, especially seeing Hook getting punched by David, even though I find that oddly hilarious 😆 I find the whole daddy-not-favoring-the-guy-daughter-brings-home thing to be realistic in a sense, why else do dads get protective of their daughters 🙂

But I don’t doubt that Hook will be the one that saves all of them, there’s no reason to lose hope 🙂

[MysteryKat25]

I just don’t get what happened…did we imagine all the CS goodness that was promised to us?

How is their interaction going to remotely fun / flirtatious etc if she’s mourning the loss of NealFire??

I can see both sides, I really can but I do have a preference and it’s CaptainSwan all the way!!!!!

I get that Neal & Emma said what they said because they were both kinda sure he was going to die on the other end of the portal (doubtful, but that’s what they believed…) and that when we do find him safe and sound they probably will skirt around it for a bit and maybe give it a go but they still have a lot of issues to work out that I will be furious if Emma just brushes them under the rug!

I’m almost kinda hoping it takes him so long to get back into the picture that Hook is able to step in but not too fast (no rebounds, totally destroys it).

I was hoping back in Tallahassee that she would have started something with Hook long before Neal came back into the picture but now….what happened?!?!?

I do get both sides but I coulda sworn we were supposed to get a lot of Hook & Emma too….*screams*

If we have to get used to the other for endgame then fine I’ll deal with it eventually but right now they were supposed to give us something good and now all I’m hearing is SwanFire fans celebrating endgame at the end of S2. I need help!!! *stares at the picture Obisgirl gave us* *tries to breathe*

On the bright side we should be getting lots of Hook next week and I’m looking forward to seeing how he is with young Bae (I adore Dylan – can we go back to shipping Bae with Wendy or Morraine or somebody who isn’t Emma in the long run?? grrrrr I don’t wannnna give up on my ship) 🙁

We were promised better than this. What happened??

Keeper of Hook's Trenchcoat.

[MysteryKat25]

Something to add:

Depending on how long Emma believes Neal to be dead, she may eventually open her heart to someone else (just like she did before after Neal the first time around, and then Graham). It may take awhile so we may not get tons next week (grrr, we were promised and there were HUGE hints at PaleyFest!) but now that’s blown out of the water. Hopefully next season it’s there.

So it’ll be 1 of 2 things:

1) Neal is found quickly and they start something but then finally address the past / figure out they’re different people and the important thing is to be around for Henry

2) Emma believes Neal to be dead for quite some time, eventually opens up to Hook (hopefully after a realistic amount of time which means waiting a;lskjdfa;slkd) and then is deeply into that when Neal shows back up and the triangle truly begins again.

I’m kinda liking the first option actually, more hope for endgame even if we have to bite our tongues and listen to everyone else celebrate for awhile.

I really feel like even though they get equal love and hate for both ships that we’ve been shafted, because they kept hinting at it and then bam, huge SwanFire moments and nothing for us.

They’re either ending the triangle and giving us somebody else for Hook, or making us wait cause with what they did tonight there’s no way we’re getting a lot of CS goodness next week unless Hook is super understanding and comforts her? (Oh hey, there’s a good idea…that could be good, but then we’d have to listen to cries of “Rebound!!!” for forever)

I’m not liking the looks of it right now….starting to panic…

Love Dylan, am happy we’re seeing him but really sad he couldn’t end up with Wendy or something (unless that’s still a possibility, or perhaps a descendant or something).

I need hope people! I get the appeal of SwanFire but I was under the impression it would be a real triangle and BOTH sides would have something to work with this season. *SIGH*

Keeper of Hook's Trenchcoat.

[craxyfox]

that’s the thing though isn’t it, people think Emma & Neal are “endgame”, however it’s only season 2
I’m hoping there will be at least 2 more seasons, so we can’t pinpoint what ‘end game’ even is 😆

I just think it seems all too easy, and maybe that’s their way of diverting our attention 😆
but yes, bright side there will be more Hook next week for sure 🙂

[MysteryKat25]

There should definitely be lots more Hook and hopefully he can change peoples minds a bit. I’m seriously sick and tired of reading all the Hook hatred and people are now celebrating in other threads saying that “everything will be alright. CaptainSwan is dead.” … Seriously??

Having serious trouble biting my tongue over there even though I get why they’re celebrating and they have every right to but that’s not very respectful. It’s like cheering that Graham died or August was turned back into a boy – it killed somebody’s ships. We’re all Oncers here, can’t we get along / be respectful of everybody liking different things? It’s one thing to celebrate something good for YOUR character / ship / etc, but to celebrate that somebody else in the fandom isn’t getting what they want is seriously upsetting. I thought we were better than that around here.

I get the SwanFire stuff, they had good moments tonight, first time I’ve actually liked them a bit but they have a long way to go to win me over completely just because of the stuff from the past that still hasn’t been addressed fully.

They can enjoy it for this week and maybe even the whole summer *sigh* but I hope we get something in the future to give us some hope again. Seriously what happened to all those hints that were leaning strongly in CS’s favor?? What gives?

Keeper of Hook's Trenchcoat.

[craxyfox]

yea, I read somewhere that the Once fandom is pretty nasty 🙁
there’s hate everywhere, I mean we all have the one thing in common, which is loving this show
I for one would never overtly show hate towards anyone/any ships, but it does feel like some hardcore shippers can’t refrain their dislikes
especially when fans attack the actors,writers and creators, it’s pretty sad 🙁

I wish we could just all ship and let ship and not rub everything in everyones faces
we just can’t let other people try to bring us down and don’t give up our hopes 🙂

[craxyfox]

they’re in the same room
breathing the same air
Hook knows where Emma lives
this makes me happy enough 😆

Moderator’s Edit: Sorry, but this is from an upcoming episode and therefore needs spoiler tags. Thanks–RG

[obisgirl]

@obisgirl wrote:

I feel like we really need this now.

@MysteryKat25 wrote:

I*stares at the picture Obisgirl gave us* *tries to breathe*

there’s also this I posted a few pages back.

@obisgirl wrote:

That’s for sure! They’re very alike. Just like Hook, Emma was a rebel when she was younger. She committed some petty theft and lived outside the law. Another thing that they have in common is that Hook and Emma both lost their love a few years back. They’re undeniably attracted to each other. But, for the time being, Emma resists the temptation to be seduced because she wants to protect Henry over all. However their relationship could take a new turn soon.

Jennifer Morrison when asked about Hook and Emma’s very ambiguous relationship.

from captainsfire

Interesting choice of words she uses. 😆 😆

[Author]

Posts