- This topic has 12,956 replies, 132 voices, and was last updated 8 years, 10 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
HA THIS MAKES ME LAUGH SO HARD
[x] HA HA HA OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
[adrotate group="5"]LAUGHING SO HARD RIGHT NOW HAHA
[x] LOVE THIS!!!! Hehehehehe 🙂
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHa…………. I LOVE THIS!
I had the same reaction @emmajones!!! 🙂
Aurora wrote: I actually have a question: SFers seem to be convinced that Emma doesn’t know that Hook “stole” Milah from Rumple (and Bae). What do you guys think?
I really cannot stand that SF ‘shippers don’t give Emma enough credit for her street smarts. There’s this belief that Emma and Team Princesses were going to die in season 2 winter finale. No, they weren’t. I figured out that twist that they would probably use the squid ink on the scroll moments before they used. It wasn’t difficult foreshadowing to decipher. And this, that Emma hasn’t figured out that Hook stole Milah from Rumple business? First of all, you don’t steal a person. Milah was a human being and she made a choice to leave Rumple for Hook. It sucks for Rumple that she made that decision but it was her decision to make. And it’s already been confirmed by Hook that Milah chose him. Second of all, Emma is smart. She knows that Milah was Neal’s mom and she knows that Milah was Hook’s lover. She’s not an idiot.
I completely agree @obisgirl. It continually amazes me how different each sides interpretations are. I saw one SF shipper saying that Emma being away from Neal causes her pain and that’s what she meant in the Echo Cave? What?? That’s not what she said AT ALL. She hoped he was DEAD for goodness sake.
I saw one SF shipper saying that Emma being away from Neal causes her pain and that’s what she meant in the Echo Cave?
LOL omg. That shipper is in deNEAL haha
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
[x] WOW this gifset is cool! 🙂
@emmajones you still around?? How are you? 🙂
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
Aurora wrote: I actually have a question: SFers seem to be convinced that Emma doesn’t know that Hook “stole” Milah from Rumple (and Bae). What do you guys think?
I really cannot stand that SF ‘shippers don’t give Emma enough credit for her street smarts. There’s this belief that Emma and Team Princesses were going to die in season 2 winter finale. No, they weren’t. I figured out that twist that they would probably use the squid ink on the scroll moments before they used. It wasn’t difficult foreshadowing to decipher. And this, that Emma hasn’t figured out that Hook stole Milah from Rumple business? First of all, you don’t steal a person. Milah was a human being and she made a choice to leave Rumple for Hook. It sucks for Rumple that she made that decision but it was her decision to make. And it’s already been confirmed by Hook that Milah chose him. Second of all, Emma is smart. She knows that Milah was Neal’s mom and she knows that Milah was Hook’s lover. She’s not an idiot.
I completely agree @obisgirl. It continually amazes me how different each sides interpretations are. I saw one SF shipper saying that Emma being away from Neal causes her pain and that’s what she meant in the Echo Cave? What?? That’s not what she said AT ALL. She hoped he was DEAD for goodness sake.
And one true love hoping their significant other is actually the opposite of how most true love’s feel when one of them dies. True Love’s hate being separated. As a rumbelle ‘shipper, I don’t like when they’re separated but like Jane said, obstacles are a part of romance. But that thinking that being separated from Neal causes her pain, that’s probably true to some degree but being with him doesn’t make her feel good either.
I’m going to be butt-hole-y again, but as far as i’m concerned, unless English isn’t your first language, there is no way to misinterpret what Emma said. It was very, VERY straighforward to me. She hoped he was dead because his presence causes her pain. End of story.
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
But that thinking that being separated from Neal causes her pain, that’s probably true to some degree but being with him doesn’t make her feel good either
I really think she’s going to bounce back REASONABLY quickly when he dies. Because she’s already experienced it twice, she knows what it feels like. And the last time she lost him she kissed Hook not long after. That’s against the show’s canon for TL, as you guys have said MANY times before.
The topic ‘The Captain Swan thread!’ is closed to new replies.