- This topic has 12,956 replies, 132 voices, and was last updated 8 years, 11 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
It’s okay @rumplegoldfan 🙁 I understand your frustration.
A lot of the haters’ arguments really do not make a lot of sense. I would be really shocked too if at the end of this season, it’s not clearly defined who is Emma’s True Love. But yeah, I don’t see either how she can end up with Neal.
But remember…
So…
[adrotate group="5"]I’m a little behind on all of the recent posts so I’ll just address this page for now.
Agree too @rumplegoldfan that Emma will realize that Hook is her home. Still not on board with the wedding yet. I’ll probably be owing you guys lots of cookies after the finale, but I’ll stick to my no CS wedding this season idea for now.
I’m pretty sick of the “Hook made a deal” theories out there too. Did Hook trade the Jolly Roger for a way back to Emma? Possibly, but I would hate for him to have lost his only home. Did he make a deal with WWW? No way. He’s too honourable for that. Is he working covertly with Neal? Why do Hooks actions have to revolve around Neal? I’ve listened to two podcasts so far (including this one) discussing Hooks actions in SB and how they impact on Neal or have to do with Neal in the EF. Really? Based on what exactly other than the podcasters ship ST. Daniel still thinks Hook will end up sacrificing himself for Emma (the initial reactions from this last episode). Okay, granted he doesn’t read the spoilers but this idea that Hook must sacrifice his life (or his ship) for a woman who may or may not love him but for sure doesn’t treat him with any respect is annoying me. “well, you are a pirate” (Emma), “so you’re going back to being a pirate” (Snow) Is that all they see? I felt so bad for Hook last episode, just the look he gave Emma when she was going on about his “swashbuckling adventures”. You’re right @emmajone, he’s not going to brag about his good deeds. He shouldn’t have to.
Rant over, carry on.
I wrote thoughts about this Another thing he could be hiding is that he just doesn’t want to burden Emma with how much he missed her. Remember, in Ariel, after he confessed his feelings for her, he knew it wasn’t a convenient moment to do so but he had no other choice. He didn’t want to burden her further with that. So I can see Hook making the same decision again, because once again, there’s a danger and they need to focus on that.
That is true. He hasn’t directly broached the subject of a relationship with her yet (because the timing is clearly not right). He has said some things that make it obvious he still feels the same for her as he did at the end of 3A but nothing as direct as his Neverland speeches.
As to the Hook is a villain thing I just don’t get it. It is just a reminder that two people can look at the same scene and see things VERY differently. I have read about people interpreting the broken heart scene as Hook being mean to Emma and I just don’t see that at all. I think it is just that some people want Hook to be a villain and will forever interpret all of his lines/actions as having ill intent even when there is obvious evidence to the contrary.
Thanks for the pretties @obisgirl. Anyone up for a nice glass of merlot? I’m having one and feel so much better.
Thanks for the pretties @obisgirl. Anyone up for a nice glass of merlot? I’m having one and feel so much better.
@callmeLola You read my mind!! But you are much classier! I just told my husband I have a craving for chicken wings and Pinot Grigio and told him to take me out!
Honestly, I need to not let this stuff get me so worked up! But it’s so much fun!
I haven’t watched the episode yet but from what I understand, the CS theme plays during that broken heart exchange. And if the CS theme is playing, then the scene is meant to be seen as romantic. Now, if Hook’s evil villain theme were played, that would be an entirely different music cue.
Musical cues on this show mean a lot. Looking all the way back to the 3A premiere, when Hook and Emma shared a drink on the Jolly Roger toasting Neal. As much as it was a CS scene, it wouldn’t have been right to play their theme then. It also wouldn’t been right to play ST theme either because the focus of the scene is Emma.
So instead of running the CS or ST music in the background, Isham opted for a variation of The Road to True Love from the first volume of the soundtrack. Emma’s theme, which is often sad, generally only plays when she is isolated or feels sad (the pilot, Ariel).
Wine always makes everything better, doesn’t it? Lol.
AHAHAHAH @rumplegoldfan, not that much classier, as we’re having chickefingers and soup for dinner.
I’m a little behind on all of the recent posts so I’ll just address this page for now. Agree too @rumplegoldfan that Emma will realize that Hook is her home. Still not on board with
I will owe cookies too because I agree with you. 🙂
Also, I need to start paying more attention to the music on the show.
Btw thanks to whoever posted about the CS podcast many pages back. I didn’t know it existed. It is nice to listen to a pro CS podcast for a change.
Did you all see the promo pics of Emma with tears? Next episode is going to be amazing.. (and sad)
That is true. He hasn’t directly broached the subject of a relationship with her yet (because the timing is clearly not right). He has said some things that make it obvious he still feels the same for her as he did at the end of 3A but nothing as direct as his Neverland speeches. As to the Hook is a villain thing I just don’t get it. It is just a reminder that two people can look at the same scene and see things VERY differently. I have read about people interpreting the broken heart scene as Hook being mean to Emma and I just don’t see that at all. I think it is just that some people want Hook to be a villain and will forever interpret all of his lines/actions as having ill intent even when there is obvious evidence to the contrary.
Agreed.
Haters are gonna hate no matter what the evidence points too- we’ll see the elephant standing the clearing, they’ll say there’s only a mouse- because they dont want to see the elephant & nothing we can ever say will change that.
I dont like the way Emma is treating Killian atm, but I can understand why she does, so I’m not ticked off with her just yet over it- I do hope it doest go on for very long though (as someone else already pointed out- sorry forget who it was), it’ll get old fast if it continues for to long- We do have to remember that Emma just broke up with a guy she loved enough to consider marrying, so we do have to cut her some slack- however I do totally agree her hostility towards the one unrelated guy who loves her, is wearing thin, esp since it was only a few eps ago that they had FINALLY got to the ‘admit I feel something for you, with out actually coming right out with ‘I love yous’ place’.
I really hoe they do go back to EF, I think it’ll help shake things up more.
The topic ‘The Captain Swan thread!’ is closed to new replies.